WW/TRUCKINGRA
North America Scraps 15,000 More Railcars a Year Than It Builds
Trinity CEO Bill Stephens says 15,000 fewer railcars are built than scrapped each year, lease rates are climbing, and 2025 builds will strain suppliers as steel costs jump 63%.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- Amara Osei
- Filed
- Length
- 651 words
- Read
- 3 min

Key points05
- North America scraps ~40,000 railcars a year against ~25,000 new builds in 2024 — a 15,000-unit deficit running 17 straight months.
- Fleet storage is down to 17.5%, the lowest since 2022; Trinity posted an 89% lease renewal rate last quarter.
- Trinity expects 2025 builds of 30,000–35,000 units; new car orders for 2027 delivery rose about 40%.
- Steel prices rose 63% year over year through Q3, plus another 5–6% since.
- Organized thieves are stopping trains in Tehachapi Pass by cutting air hoses; CORCA cargo-theft legislation remains unpassed despite bipartisan support.
North American railroads are retiring roughly 40,000 railcars a year while building fewer than 25,000 — a 15,000-unit annual deficit that has now compressed the fleet for 17 consecutive months. That's the number doing all the work in the railcar market right now, and Trinity Industries CEO Bill Stephens doesn't see it closing before 2027.
The math is getting harder to ignore. Storage levels have fallen to 17.5% of the North American fleet, the lowest since 2022, and lease rates are climbing with them. Stephens, whose leasing segment he described as the larger part of Trinity's business, says utilization is high and rates are moving up, even as new car manufacturing stays depressed at the bottom of a prolonged down cycle.
What does this change for shippers?
Mostly the price of waiting. Trinity's third-quarter earnings call showed a book-to-bill ratio above 1x and a roughly 40% jump in new car orders for 2027 delivery. Stephens now expects 2025 builds of 30,000 to 35,000 units — a meaningful step up from 2024's roughly 25,000, but one that will strain a supply chain already showing cracks.
Steel producers have doubled their lead times and are still missing those extended windows by two to four weeks, he noted. Valve manufacturers for tank cars can't keep pace even at current low production levels. His advice to customers was blunt: "Stop delaying, because there are going to be some headwinds." Getting to 30,000–35,000 builds next year, he said, "is going to take the supply chain actually stretching and pushing hard to get there."
Input costs are pushing in the same direction. Steel prices were up 63% year over year at the end of the third quarter and have climbed another 5% to 6% since. Because the price of a new car effectively caps what lessors can charge for existing equipment, rising steel reinforces lease rate gains across the whole fleet. Trinity still posted an 89% lease renewal rate last quarter — customers re-signed even as rates rose. Loyalty, apparently, has a price ceiling nobody has found yet.
Where's the demand coming from?
Not from shiny new traffic, mostly. The strongest order activity sits in grain, metals and metallic ores, and petroleum — categories Stephens attributed largely to replacement needs rather than growth. He downplayed the AI infrastructure buildout as a near-term rail cargo driver, calling its contribution through construction materials and metals "small." Petroleum strength, in his view, traces back to war-related energy market disruptions, with overseas equipment damage keeping that segment elevated into at least 2028.
And the cargo theft problem
The discussion also put a spotlight on a low-tech threat moving through a high-traffic corridor. Trains Magazine contributor Bill Stevens described organized criminal crews working slow-moving trains through Tehachapi Pass in Southern California — a key corridor linking Southern California to the Bay Area and Pacific Northwest. The tactic is simple: hop aboard, cut the air hoses to stop the train, and throw consumer goods overboard.
"Clearly, they know what they're looking for and what containers they want to hit," Stevens said. This isn't opportunistic looting. It's targeting, and it's happening on a corridor that carries a meaningful share of West Coast rail freight.
Stephens and host Jean Savage both called for passage of CORCA, federal legislation that would coordinate law enforcement response to cargo theft. The bill has bipartisan support in Congress. It has not, so far, become law — a familiar Washington rhythm.
For shippers, the practical takeaway is a two-front squeeze: lease rates rising on a shrinking fleet while cargo theft adds risk on corridors like Tehachapi. With the build deficit running through at least 2027 and steel still climbing, the cheapest railcar on the market is likely the one you already have under contract.
Source: FreightWaves
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
977 articles
Related05
North American Railcar Fleet Shrinks as Carload Volumes Surge
Shipper freight costs jump 32% in Q3 — biggest rise since 2021
Truckload Spot Rates Jump 60% as 89,000 Carriers Exit the Market
89,000 truckload exits as ports and holiday demand test capacity
US Trucking Sheds 100,000 Tractors as Small Carriers Exit