WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 506W3M read

Record diesel sinks FTR shipper index to -17.3 in September

Record diesel dragged FTR's Shippers Conditions Index to -17.3 in September from -13.8, tying April as the worst month for shippers since March 2022.

By
Amara Osei
Filed
Length
506 words
Read
3 min
Diesel prices punished shippers in September, FTR says
Diesel prices punished shippers in September, FTR saysElyPenner / pixabay

Key points05

  • FTR's Shippers Conditions Index fell to -17.3 in September from a revised -13.8 in August.
  • September tied April as the second-toughest month for shippers since March 2022.
  • Record all-time-high diesel prices were the largest negative factor in the September reading.
  • FTR raised its capacity utilization forecast for the next two quarters on slow trucking payroll job growth.
  • FTR expects firmer freight rates ahead, with conditions tougher for shippers than previously estimated.

FTR's Shippers Conditions Index fell to -17.3 in September, down from a revised -13.8 in August, making the month — alongside April — the second-worst for shippers since March 2022. The culprit was record diesel, but not only diesel.

The Bloomington, Indiana-based transportation analysis firm said all-time-high fuel prices were the largest single drag on the September reading. Capacity utilization and freight rates also stayed strongly negative, compounding the squeeze.

What does the index actually measure?

The SCI rolls four conditions in the U.S. full-load freight market into one number: freight demand, freight rates, fleet capacity and fuel price. Positive means shippers have room to breathe. Negative means they don't. September's -17.3 sits deep in the red.

For context, the reading means shippers faced conditions almost as hostile as April's — and those two months now bookend the worst stretch for cargo owners in over two and a half years.

Why diesel made the difference

"The surge in fuel prices to an all-time high in September guaranteed a highly unfavorable market for shippers," Avery Vise, FTR's vice president of trucking, said in a release. "Although diesel prices are easing – at least for now – dynamics related to the freight market remain quite challenging and look to be even tougher for shippers than previously estimated."

That last clause is the part worth underlining. FTR's previous forecast already looked grim for cargo owners. It now looks grimmer.

What changes for shippers over the next two quarters?

Two things, per Vise: capacity and rates. Slow payroll job growth in trucking and other factors have pushed FTR to raise its capacity utilization expectations for the coming quarters.

Tighter utilization means firmer freight rates. For carriers, that's the first genuinely good news in a while — equipment and drivers are getting scarcer relative to demand. For shippers and the forwarders negotiating on their behalf, it means the pricing tailwind they've enjoyed is fading.

"Slow payroll job growth in trucking and other factors have led us to increase our expectations for capacity utilization over the next couple of quarters, leading to firmer freight rates, too," Vise said.

He did offer one caveat of relief: "The good news is that the overall market conditions do not look to be as difficult for shippers as they were in September – provided, of course, that diesel prices do not surge again."

That proviso is doing a lot of work. Fuel is the swing variable, and September proved how fast it can turn a bad month into a near-record one.

The practical read

Shippers budgeting for the next two quarters should assume less negotiating leverage than this year's lows implied. Carriers, meanwhile, get a slow-burn case for holding the line on rates as utilization tightens.

FTR's forward view: conditions won't be as brutal as September's -17.3, but the market looks tougher for shippers than the firm's previous forecast assumed — unless diesel has another record in it.

Original: ftrintel.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

977 articles

Related05

  1. FTR Trucking Conditions Index Slips to 8.13 as Record Fuel Costs Bite

  2. Capacity Contracts for 11th Month as Spot Rates Jump 47%

  3. Q3 freight spending jumps 32.1% as truck volumes barely rise

  4. Transportation Prices Hit 92.7 as Capacity Contracts for 10th Month

  5. TL Capacity Contracts for 11th Month as Carriers Push Double-Digit Rate Hikes

« Prev