WW/MARKETANAL

Filed 881W4M read

Truck spot rates fall as court rejects $74 million CDL funding action

Spot truckload rates fell 4.6 cents to $3.16 per mile, diesel dropped 19 cents, and an appeals court rejected FMCSA's $74 million CDL funding action in New York.

By
Marcus Bennett
Filed
Length
881 words
Read
4 min
This week in trucking: Independent contractors, non-domiciled CDLs abound
This week in trucking: Independent contractors, non-domiciled CDLs aboundrgaudet17 / pixabay

Key points02

  • Broker-posted spot rates fell 4.6 cents to $3.16 per mile; dry van was $2.89, refrigerated $3.55, and flatbed $3.18.
  • The 2nd Circuit rejected

By Marcus Bennett

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected an attempt by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to withhold $74 million in New York highway funding over non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs).

Truck spot rates fell 4.6 cents to $3.16 per mile, according to FTR Transportation Intelligence, in the November 19 weekly snapshot.

The court said FMCSA’s action was “arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law.” It also found that no rule required states to coordinate a driver’s commercial-license expiration with the driver’s legal-status expiration. The ruling rejects FMCSA’s stated legal basis for the withholding, although the legal battle may continue.

Dry van rates eased by less than 1 cent to $2.89 per mile. Refrigerated rates increased 3 cents to $3.55 per mile, while flatbed rates fell 7.6 cents to $3.18 per mile.

Applied mechanically to a 100-mile load, the total benchmark decline equals $4.60, the dry-van decline less than $1, the flatbed decline $7.60, and the refrigerated increase $3.00.

Shippers may see more leverage in dry-van and flatbed negotiations, while refrigerated pricing moved in the opposite direction. Carriers cannot infer a uniform revenue squeeze from one blended number because equipment-level pricing diverged.

The national average on-highway diesel price fell another 19 cents, to $5.94 per gallon in weekly Energy Information Administration data and $5.93 per gallon in the latest American Automobile Association figures. For much of the country, retail diesel is again below $6 per gallon despite the continuing Iran War.

Lower pump prices ease one operating-cost pressure for diesel fleets, but they do not prove stronger margins. The figures omit fuel consumption, fleet utilization, and any fuel-cost pass-through, so the net financial effect remains uncertain.

Why did FMCSA withhold the New York funding?

FMCSA announced the withholding in April as part of the Department of Transportation’s multi-state effort to press states to cancel non-domiciled commercial driver’s license programs.

The agency had demanded that multiple states pause or revoke issuance because the licenses’ expiration dates exceeded drivers’ legal-status expiration dates. New York allegedly refused to revoke the non-domiciled CDLs, prompting FMCSA to withhold the highway funding.

For New York, the appellate decision reduces the immediate risk of a $74 million funding loss through the challenged mechanism. For shippers and forwarders, the unresolved CDL program leaves interstate driver availability uncertain. For carriers and drivers, continued litigation means the operating rules remain unsettled.

What could $20 million in highway data sharing do?

The Department of Transportation is launching the Great American Digital Corridors Program with $20 million in total from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill for state highway data-sharing projects. The program seeks to modernize how states share highway safety data and prioritizes real-time integration for work-zone safety, congestion reduction, and emergency response.

Carriers and forwarders could use better-connected work-zone and congestion information to adjust routes and arrival estimates if participating states link those systems. That remains a potential benefit rather than a measured one: the announcement provides no awardees, completion dates, expected delay reductions, or truck-capacity gains.

What changes under the independent-contractor rulemaking?

The Department of Labor is again using a final rulemaking to re-implement the first Trump administration’s interpretation of independent-contractor status in some lawsuits. The new interpretation departs from case law to simplify how the department determines whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

If a worker sues a company claiming employee protections, the interpretation may make it easier for the company to argue that the worker was an independent contractor and therefore outside many FLSA protections.

For trucking employers, the commercial issue is the strength of that defense in covered classification disputes, not a blanket reclassification of every contractor. The rulemaking does not by itself resolve how courts will apply the interpretation.

The first Trump administration tried to issue a similar final rule in January 2021, but the Biden administration canceled it in favor of a more traditional interpretation. The American Trucking Associations, a frequent and vocal supporter of the Trump interpretation for many years, celebrated the rulemaking and delivered remarks at a Department of Labor ceremony marking the occasion.

That support does not establish how courts will apply the interpretation, so carrier-industry backing should not be mistaken for a settled legal outcome.

What should freight operators watch next?

The immediate watchpoints are the November 19 rate and fuel readings: another decline in spot rates would give shippers more pricing leverage, while a rebound in refrigerated pricing would weaken any broad down-market conclusion. Policy adds two unresolved tracks in New York’s CDL funding dispute and the independent-contractor interpretation.

The available data provide no truck-capacity, fleet-utilization, tender-volume, or lane-level rate figures, so they cannot establish whether the broader freight market is entering a contraction or recovery.

Rates may stay soft if the 4.6-cent benchmark decline and 19-cent diesel drop persist, but the mixed equipment benchmarks make a firm forecast premature; the CDL funding case and contractor interpretation remain the near-term policy tests.

Source: fleetowner.com

Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

1,006 articles

Related05

  1. Appeals Court Restores $73.5M in Federal Highway Funds to New York

  2. Diesel slips to $6.20, but truckload spot rates still outpace seasonal norms

  3. USDOT Puts $200 Million Behind Truck Parking Shortage

  4. U.S. dry van spot volumes plunge 32.1% in August as rates hold firm

  5. Barron's Law Would Fine Carriers $25,000 Per Unqualified Trucker

« Prev