WW/TRUCKINGRA
Tender rejection costs jump to 10.69% as truckload backups bite
SONAR's Routing Guide Premium for 2nd tenders hit 10.69%, the highest since September, as primary acceptance slid to 88.06% ahead of Thanksgiving truckload capacity squeezes.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- Marcus Bennett
- Filed
- Length
- 679 words
- Read
- 3 min
Key points05
- Routing Guide Premium for 2nd tender rose to 10.69% on Thursday, up 1.87 points from 8.82% a week earlier — highest since September.
- Primary tender acceptance (RGAS1.USA) fell 88 basis points week over week to 88.06%, its lowest since September.
- A year ago a primary acceptance failure cost about 4%; it expanded to roughly 8% by Christmas.
- Contract tender lead times run about 3.7 days versus roughly one day for spot loads, making contract data a leading disruption indicator.
- National Truckload Index spot rates were flat to slightly lower week over week as of Nov. 19.
The cost of a rejected truckload tender climbed to 10.69% on Thursday, up 1.87 percentage points from 8.82% a week earlier and the highest reading since September, according to FreightWaves SONAR data.
The move landed in the run-up to Thanksgiving, the stretch when holiday freight typically starts to squeeze truckload capacity. At the same time, the Routing Guide Acceptance Share for the first, or primary, tender (RGAS1.USA) slid to 88.06% — down 88 basis points week over week and also its lowest level since September.
Put plainly: fewer loads are sticking with the primary carrier, and the backup carriers further down shippers' routing guides are charging more to take them.
What does the routing guide premium actually measure?
SONAR's Routing Guide Premium for the 2nd tender (RGP2.USA) measures the difference in all-in cost — including fuel and accessorial charges — between the primary carrier and the carriers deeper in a shipper's routing guide. It is the price a shipper pays when its first-choice carrier says no.
Heading into the holiday period, shippers' routing guides put the cost of a primary acceptance failure at roughly 8.8%. In about a week, that premium jumped nearly 2 percentage points, and the trajectory suggests it will go higher still. For comparison: a year ago, a primary acceptance failure cost around 4%, and that premium expanded to around 8% by Christmas.
Premiums move inversely to tender acceptance, and they tend to move slowly — until they don't. Sharp moves around holidays and market disruptions can blow up shippers' contingency budgets in days.
Why backup carriers won't hold the line
The rapid expansion in cost is a critical detail that many transportation managers miss when selecting providers and building routing guides, and the data here should temper any assumption that a deep routing guide equals cheap insurance.
Secondary carriers typically face the same capacity pressure as primary carriers. Because they are not a top priority for the shipper, the shipper is not a top priority for them. When the whole market is under pressure and spot rates climb, a carrier has little reason to haul freight below market rates for business it will not keep once the market stabilizes.
Some of the increase comes from contract-plus pricing, in which the shipper adds an amount on top of the standard contract rate for the primary carrier. That structure keeps the shipper from having to turn to the spot market, or to ask a carrier unfamiliar with its freight to go out of its way, at a much higher cost to serve.
Is the contract market signaling before spot rates do?
This premium does not show up directly in spot rate indices, because the freight is not technically spot freight. Contract tenders carry much longer lead times than spot loads — currently around 3.7 days versus roughly a single day — which often makes the contract market a leading indicator of market disruption.
That leading-indicator role is worth watching now. As of Thursday, Nov. 19, shippers were already feeling the pain of deteriorating carrier compliance even though spot rates, as measured by the National Truckload Index (NTI), were flat to slightly lower week over week. When spot rates rise quickly, the spot market can pull capacity away from contract freight — a dynamic the tender data may be flagging ahead of the NTI.
What should shippers take from the chart?
The core lesson: contingency carriers are not a given when the market turns volatile. The market sets the cost of service in those periods, but that cost belongs in bid negotiations, because the carrier relationship has to go beyond the paper.
Carriers cannot be expected to ignore the market for a shipper that values their service only when it needs a backup. With the routing guide premium already more than double its year-ago level of roughly 4% and Thanksgiving capacity pressure still building, the cost of a failed tender looks set to keep rising into December — mirroring last year's climb to about 8% by Christmas.
Original: getfreightdata.com
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
1,006 articles
Related05
SONAR Puts a Price on Routing Guide Failure: 22% on Second Tender
Rejected Loads Cost Shippers 20% More as Contract Resets Hit 13%
Graypool Exchange opens with seven founding truckload carriers
Pricing Power Index Hits 70, Fourth Straight Drop, Carriers Still Rule
US Contract Truckload Rates Hit 52-Week High of $2.72/Mile