WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 729W4M read

Freight Inflation's Q3 Winners and Losers: Railroads Gain as Ford Eats $2 Billion

Ford faces a $2B cost headwind while Gulf-Asia crude shipping jumps from $5 to $30-35 per barrel; railroads and Gulf Coast refiners emerge as Q3 freight inflation winners.

By
Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
729 words
Read
4 min
Rising Q3 transportation costs squeeze manufacturers, reward railroads and reshape trade
Rising Q3 transportation costs squeeze manufacturers, reward railroads and reshape tradeNiklas9416 / pixabay

Key points05

  • Ford CEO Jim Farley expects commodities, memory and logistics costs to be a ~$2 billion year-over-year headwind
  • U.S. Gulf Coast-to-Asia crude shipping costs jumped from about $5 to $30–$35 per barrel in a year
  • XPO cut outsourced miles from ~25% to 5.6% and saw fuel, opex and supplies costs rise $66 million, or 29%
  • Union Pacific said fuel prices hurt its Q3 operating ratio by 140 basis points despite record revenue
  • Rail executives at UP, Norfolk Southern and CSX see higher fuel costs shifting freight to intermodal rail

Ford expects commodities, memory and logistics costs to hit its results with a year-over-year headwind of about $2 billion, Chief Executive Jim Farley told investors during third-quarter earnings season. That figure, spread across a company that ships millions of vehicles and parts annually, frames how transportation inflation is now redrawing corporate economics — punishing some manufacturers while handing railroads and Gulf Coast refiners a competitive edge.

Comments from seven executives at Ford (NYSE: F), Union Pacific (NYSE: UNP), XPO (NYSE: XPO) and Valero (NYSE: VLO) show that the impact of rising fuel prices and freight rates depends less on who pays more for diesel than on how far a company ships, which transport networks it controls, and whether its competitors face an even steeper freight bill.

At Ford, Chief Financial Officer Sherry Ann House drew a line between the cost of moving vehicles and customers' willingness to buy them. "Higher fuel prices are impacting our freight and energy costs. But notably, we are not seeing it impact customer demand for trucks and fleet vehicles at this point," House said on the company's earnings call. Farley's $2 billion estimate combines several expense categories, and both executives said growth elsewhere in the business, including software services and parts, was helping offset the increases.

For manufacturers, the burden extends beyond delivering finished products. Automotive parts can cross borders repeatedly before final assembly, leaving supply chains exposed to higher fuel costs at multiple stages of production.

Why are railroads winning?

Union Pacific Chief Executive Jim Vena described the same fuel-price pressure as a potential source of new business. "Railroads are much more efficient. It costs us way less per ton to move products across the U.S. So when fuel prices go up, it's naturally an advantage," Vena told investors on the company's October 22 earnings call.

Executives at Union Pacific, Norfolk Southern (NYSE: NSC) and CSX (NASDAQ: CSX) said higher fuel costs and a tightening trucking market were pushing freight toward intermodal rail. The advantage came with a cost of its own: Union Pacific said fuel prices hurt its third-quarter operating ratio by 140 basis points, even as revenue climbed — record top-line and profit results alongside the squeeze.

How is XPO insulating itself?

At less-than-truckload specialist XPO, executives emphasized control over transportation capacity rather than relief from market rates. Chief Financial Officer Kyle Wismans said the company's combined fuel, operating expense and supplies category increased 29%, or $66 million, from a year earlier, primarily because of higher fuel prices. Purchased transportation costs rose another $10 million amid increased freight volume and rising truckload rates.

Chief Executive Mario Harik pointed to the company's effort to bring more hauling in-house. XPO cut outsourced miles from roughly 25% when the program began to 5.6% in the third quarter, limiting its reliance on outside carriers as rates climbed. Harik said rising truckload rates were lowering the break-even point for insourcing, and the company does not expect to increase its exposure to outsourced miles. Owning and operating capacity, in short, provides a buffer when buying transportation on the open market becomes expensive.

What about oil markets and refiners?

For refiner Valero, soaring tanker costs changed the relative attractiveness of crude supplies and export markets. "The main story right now in the market is freight rates," said Randy Hawkins, vice president of crude and feedstocks supply and trading, on a post-earnings conference call. Shipping crude from the U.S. Gulf Coast to Asia now costs $30–$35 a barrel, compared with about $5 a year earlier — roughly a sixfold increase.

Those costs have deepened discounts on some heavy crude grades, benefiting Gulf Coast refiners able to source supplies closer to home. Chief Operating Officer Gary Simmons identified a parallel advantage on the sales side. "Higher freight rates actually give us an advantage into the typical export markets into Latin America," Simmons said, explaining that Valero primarily competes with European barrels in those markets.

Across the earnings calls, executives portrayed freight costs not only as a margin risk but as a force reshaping where companies buy inputs, how they move goods, and which markets they can serve competitively. With fuel prices and truckload rates still climbing into the fourth quarter, the divergence between capacity owners and capacity buyers looks set to widen.

Original: getfreightdata.com

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

929 articles

Related05

  1. AI Chip Squeeze, $5 Diesel and $3bn Honda Bet Reshape Freight

  2. Diesel Up 72% Is Devouring Truckload Carriers' Hard-Won Rate Gains

  3. Truckers raise alarm as diesel pressure outruns contracts

  4. Diesel surge pushes US truckers into fresh round of cost defenses

  5. Diesel Squeeze Pinches Truckers, Groceries in the Crosshairs

« PrevNext »