WW/MARKETANAL

Filed 703W4M read

Truckload rejections hit 12.8%, but the holiday market remains flat

Truckload rejections reached 12.8%, double last year, but momentum stalled. Reefer and flatbed rates strengthened while dry van stayed flat ahead of Thanksgiving and the 2026 contract season.

By
James Calloway
Filed
Length
703 words
Read
4 min
Trucking Market: Why Is It Flat Despite 12.8% Rejection?
Trucking Market: Why Is It Flat Despite 12.8% Rejection?rauschenberger / pixabay

Key points05

  • Truckload tender rejections held at 12.8%, versus 6% at the same point last year.
  • The overall rejection index slipped about 1 percentage point over the latest 20 days.
  • November’s outbound tender volume averaged 11,434, up 12% year over year and about 3% from October.
  • Reefer tender rejections reached 21%, compared with 12.6% a year earlier.
  • C.H. Robinson’s flatbed cost-per-mile forecast calls for 28% year-over-year growth in 2026 and another 10% in 2027.

By James Calloway

Truckload tender rejections held at 12.8%, roughly double the 6% recorded at the same point last year, yet the overall rejection index slipped about 1 percentage point over the latest 20 days. That combination points to loose capacity, not the broad tightening normally associated with peak season.

FreightWaves data analysts Julie Van de Kamp and Craig Fuller described demand beginning to build without matching pricing momentum. Van de Kamp said:

“I would like to see a little bit more heat, a little bit more pressure — that would tell us that this market is going to be strong in ’27. We’re not seeing it yet.”

November’s Outbound Tender Volume Index averages 11,434, 12% above November last year and roughly 3% above October. Fuller said:

“We are seeing 12% more demand this year than last November, and we’re up about 3% from October. So we’re seeing demand pick up.”

That volume gain represents the first meaningful holiday demand build, but it has not produced a comparable jump in tender rejections. The two indicators are sending shippers and carriers different messages: more freight is entering the system, while the market still lacks the heat Van de Kamp wants before 2027.

Why are truckload rates flat?

Spot rate data shows three different equipment markets:

  • Refrigerated rates broke out sharply in July and have remained elevated.
  • Flatbed rates are holding at a premium, supported by AI data center construction and industrial activity.
  • Dry van rates have largely flattened.

That divergence leaves shippers paying more for refrigerated and flatbed capacity while dry van offers a softer pricing option. Carriers in the first two modes have stronger revenue prospects; dry-van operators have less leverage. Forwarders cannot treat truckload as one pricing environment.

Fuller, citing C.H. Robinson’s earnings commentary, said the company’s 2026 flatbed cost-per-mile forecast stands 28% above last year, with another 10% projected for 2027. If that forecast holds, shippers face continued pressure in flatbed budgets while carriers retain a firmer basis for pricing.

What is tightening refrigerated capacity?

Reefer tender rejections are running at 21%, compared with 12.6% at the same time last year. Thanksgiving-related food shipments and tightening capacity have made refrigerated freight the standout segment. For shippers, that means a thinner capacity cushion; for carriers, it strengthens the case for holding rates; for forwarders, it raises the cost of assembling capacity around food and protect-from-freeze loads.

Van de Kamp said a forecast for a super El Niño, which some forecasters are calling the strongest in over 100 years, could add pressure on reefer capacity this winter. The greatest exposure is protect-from-freeze freight carrying food products and electronics.

A severe winter could narrow shippers’ and forwarders’ options precisely when demand rises, potentially lifting rates. Carriers could benefit if the squeeze persists, while winter weather creates the opposite risk if severe conditions remove capacity from the network.

Where is demand tightening first?

The Pacific Northwest is beginning to tighten as apple, potato and Christmas tree harvests ramp up. Van de Kamp said the regional market stays nearly dead for nine months of the year before flipping sharply, making the harvest period the first clear test of seasonal pricing pressure.

C.H. Robinson also noted in its earnings that early November typically brings some rate relief before Thanksgiving, but that this year’s relief may be more limited than usual. For regional shippers, less relief would mean the seasonal harvest lift arrives with less price easing than in a typical year.

Can this become a tight market?

Both analysts said the next two weeks around Thanksgiving, with year-end freight behind it, will be the clearest test of whether the market has enough momentum to set up a tighter environment heading into the 2026 contract season. Continued flatness would leave the outlook for 2027 contract rates unsettled and give shippers less reason to expect broad rate increases.

Winter weather remains an additional wildcard for capacity, especially in refrigerated freight. The next two weeks will determine whether rising holiday volumes finally produce broad rate pressure or leave truckload split between elevated reefer, premium flatbed and comparatively soft dry van.

Original: getfreightdata.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

921 articles

Related05

  1. Dry Van Rejections Near 11% as Reefer Market Tightens Further

  2. Truckload Tender Volume Jumps 5% as Van Spot Rates Hit $3.49 a Mile

  3. Truckload Capacity Shows No Sign of Coming Back

  4. Truckload spot rates jump over 50% before Thanksgiving peak

  5. Tender Rejections at 2.5x Last Year: SONAR's Case for Partner of Choice

« PrevNext »