WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 626W3M read

Proficient Auto Logistics to Walk Away From Unprofitable Contracts

Proficient Auto Logistics booked 10%-plus rate hikes on $25 million of replaced contracts as its Q3 net loss tripled to $9.9 million and OR hit 99.8%.

By
Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
626 words
Read
3 min
Proficient executives target contract hikes, say they’ll walk away from work where they can’t offset rising costs
Proficient executives target contract hikes, say they’ll walk away from work where they can’t offset rising costsrauschenberger / pixabay

Key points05

  • Proficient's Q3 net loss grew to $9.9 million from $3.0 million a year earlier, on revenues of nearly $149 million.
  • The company replaced about $25 million of business since early September at average rate increases above 10%.
  • Hansen & Adkins integration savings guidance rose to $20-30 million from an initial $6-10 million target.
  • Shares fell 14% to $2.62 on November 13; market cap is now about $73 million, a fifth of mid-2024 levels.
  • Proficient targets a 95-97% operating ratio next year and 92-94% the year after.

Proficient Auto Logistics booked an average rate increase of more than 10% on roughly $25 million of replaced business since early September, as the country's largest auto hauler moves to push contract pricing back toward market levels after a quarter in which its net loss more than tripled.

The Jacksonville, Florida-based company reported a third-quarter net loss of $9.9 million, up from $3.0 million a year earlier, despite operating revenues climbing to nearly $149 million from $114 million. Proficient delivered more than 839,000 vehicles in the quarter, with about 372,000 of those moved by company trucks rather than subhaulers. Higher fuel, driver and maintenance costs, combined with lagging fuel recoveries and contract pricing below today's market, drove the adjusted operating ratio to 99.8%, deteriorating from 96.3% in the 2025 quarter.

What are executives doing about pricing?

Chairman and CEO Rick O'Dell said on the post-earnings call that his teams are "actively engaging" with auto manufacturers on fuel surcharges, but that the margin repair work will take beyond the fourth quarter to fully materialize. The roughly $25 million in replaced contracts since the beginning of September, booked at increases above 10%, marks the first measurable payoff of that effort.

President and COO Amy Rice told analysts the broader network Proficient gained through its August acquisition of Hansen & Adkins is helping it capture more spot business to offset contractual weakness. That weakness also constrains capacity, because drivers and subhaulers are typically paid a share of revenues. Proficient is targeting the bottom 20% of its portfolio.

"We are working with customers to improve economics at the bottom 20% of our portfolio contract locations by profitability, including those locations with impaired profitability due to fuel," Rice said. "Where we cannot establish acceptable economics, we will facilitate transition out of such business and redeploy that capacity."

Why is the recovery expected to be slow?

Stifel analysts, led by Bruce Chan, told investors on November 13 that they view the Proficient story as intact but requiring patience. The company's heavy share of business with auto OEMs means contractual improvements will arrive more slowly than at other carriers.

"We think the primary risk remains duration," the analysts wrote. "In the early stages of the cycle, Proficient continues to absorb margin compression as costs increase ahead of contract renewals, and even with better pricing, continued cost inflation could limit margin recovery."

One financial bright spot has grown considerably. Anticipated savings from the Hansen & Adkins purchase and integration have risen to between $20 million and $30 million, up sharply from the $6 million to $10 million O'Dell and his team targeted this summer. Those benefits will accrue in stages through 2029, with cost-cutting initiatives giving way to other efficiencies and what O'Dell called "the stronger value proposition that we now present in the market."

Where does the company go from here?

O'Dell said Proficient is targeting an operating ratio of 95% to 97% next year as savings and price increases flow through the income statement. For the following year, the goal drops further, to between 92% and 94%.

Investors showed little patience for the timeline. Shares of Proficient (Ticker: PAL) fell 14% to $2.62 on November 13 and slipped further the following Monday. The stock has lost half its value over the past six months, cutting the company's market capitalization to about $73 million — one-fifth of its level in mid-2024, shortly after going public.

With the bottom fifth of its contract book now under formal review and more than $20 million in integration savings staged through 2029, Proficient enters 2026 betting that OEM customers will accept higher rates rather than lose capacity to competitors.

Source: fleetowner.com

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

931 articles

Related05

  1. Proficient Auto Logistics Posts $10M Loss, Sees 2027 Margin Repair

  2. Truckload rates firm as 70,000 drivers leave the market

  3. US Contract Truckload Rates Hit 52-Week High of $2.72/Mile

  4. Diesel at Record $6.53 Pushes 16 US Trucking Firms Into Bankruptcy

  5. US driver pay keeps climbing as trucking exits four-year slump

« Prev