WW/TRUCKINGRA
J.B. Hunt Cleared of Vicarious Liability, but Negligent Hiring Claim Goes to Trial
An Arizona court cleared J.B. Hunt of vicarious liability for a fatal 2023 crash on a $1,350 load, but ruled a jury must weigh its vetting of carrier Borderlanders.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- Elena Vasquez
- Filed
- Length
- 820 words
- Read
- 4 min

Key points05
- Arizona federal court granted one summary judgment and denied another for J.B. Hunt in Gee vs. J.B. Hunt, sending the negligent hiring claim forward.
- The October 2023 crash on U.S. Route 160 killed two parents and injured three children; the load paid $1,350 from Denver to Phoenix for Lincare.
- The court found no lease existed, blocking vicarious liability under federal leasing regulations.
- Judge McNamee cited evidence J.B. Hunt never reviewed Borderlanders' FMCSA safety scores or crash history before booking.
- The case follows the Supreme Court's Montgomery ruling and echoes the $600 million-plus C.H. Robinson verdict in Texas.
An Arizona federal court has cleared J.B. Hunt's brokerage of vicarious liability for a fatal 2023 crash, while ruling that its decision to hire the carrier involved — Borderlanders Inc. — must be decided by a jury. The split summary judgment, handed down Thursday by the U.S. District Court for Arizona in Crystal Gee et al. vs. J.B. Hunt et al., makes the case one of the first key tests of broker liability after the Supreme Court's ruling in Montgomery vs. Caribe Transport II reshaped the legal ground beneath brokers.
The $1,350 load at the center of the litigation was booked by Borderlanders off J.B. Hunt's online brokerage platform. Medical equipment supplier Lincare had hired J.B. Hunt to move the freight from Denver to Phoenix.
What happened on Route 160?
The crash occurred in October 2023. According to Judge Stephen McNamee's recap of the facts, employee driver Shokhijakhon Bekmuradov crossed into oncoming traffic on U.S. Route 160, a two-lane highway, and did not immediately return to his lane. A car carrying Gregory Cox, his partner Lindsey Watson and their three children came around a corner and collided head-on with the truck. Cox and Watson were killed; the three children were seriously injured. Plaintiff Crystal Gee is the guardian of the surviving children and filed suit in March 2024.
What did the court accept and reject?
J.B. Hunt, which trades on NASDAQ as JBHT, sought summary judgment on two grounds and won one:
- Granted: dismissal of claims that it was vicariously liable for the driver's actions and that Bekmuradov was a "statutory employee." The court found no lease existed between broker and carrier. "Borderlanders transported the Load under its own authority using its own equipment and driver," McNamee wrote, so the federal leasing regulations that could have imposed vicariously liability "are inapplicable" because they "apply only if there is a valid lease."
- Denied: dismissal of the negligent hiring claim. The plaintiffs "have presented sufficient evidence in which a rational jury could find that J.B. Hunt knew, or should have known, of the safety risks associated in selecting Borderlanders," the judge wrote.
J.B. Hunt declined comment, citing the ongoing litigation.
The company's original defense rested on the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (F4A), arguing that state action touching "price, route or service" was precluded and that the F4A safety exception — which permits state claims tied to motor vehicles — did not cover brokers. That argument died with the Montgomery ruling, forcing a new approach.
What does the carrier-vetting record show?
J.B. Hunt argued the plaintiffs produced no evidence of a checkered past at Borderlanders. The judge disagreed, citing the plaintiffs' claim that "J.B. Hunt never reviewed Borderlanders' publicly available accident and crash history, and FMCSA safety scores, safety assessment alerts, and inspection violation history before selecting Borderlanders."
Borderlanders itself is no longer part of the action. The carrier settled with the plaintiffs, and the case against Bekmuradov was dismissed voluntarily with prejudice. J.B. Hunt contended that without an underlying tort claim against Borderlanders, the negligent hiring claim fails — an argument McNamee declined to accept.
Why does this matter beyond one case?
Gregory Reed, a partner at Hanson Bridgett who heads the firm's transportation practice, called J.B. Hunt's arguments "common refrains in the broker and logistics industry" — but also "unavailing." He identified two strands: first, that "Borderlanders remained a FMCSA-authorized (albeit unrated) carrier thus brokers should be free to use such carriers insulated from negligence"; second, that "Borderlanders' safety and performance record was insufficient to provide JB Hunt notice because negative incidents were few compared to the carrier's number of drivers and volume of loads."
The first argument touches the industry's central post-Montgomery complaint: brokers still lack federal guidance on what vetting steps protect them from negligent hiring claims. That gap was stark in the recent Texas verdict against C.H. Robinson, where a judge upheld a more than $600 million award after a 2021 wreck that killed three people — even though the carrier involved held a Satisfactory FMCSA rating. The J.B. Hunt case is different in one key respect: court filings repeatedly reference a weak safety record at Borderlanders, muddying any defense that its vetting was adequate.
"Both arguments go to the duty of care a company like JB Hunt is required to exercise based on what it should have known, and their failure at this stage in the case demonstrates that courts may be unlikely to take these cases out of the hands of the jury to determine reasonableness," Reed said.
With the negligent hiring claim intact, a jury may now decide what a broker's duty of care means when the public record flags risk — a verdict that would land as brokers and 3PLs continue pressing federal regulators for clearer carrier-selection standards.
Original: getfreightdata.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
996 articles
Related05
New Mexico Jury Hits Pilot Thomas Logistics With $47M Tanker Crash Verdict
Supreme Court Revives Shipper Liability Case in Wake of Montgomery
Carriers' $150M RICO Threat Against TQL and C.H. Robinson Faces Long Odds
C.H. Robinson appeals $604m verdict that could reshape broker liability
C.H. Robinson's $604M Verdict Signals a Liability Shift Brokers Can't Ignore