WW/TRUCKINGRA
Supreme Court Revives Shipper Liability Case in Wake of Montgomery
The Supreme Court's GVR order in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms revives the question of whether shippers and receivers like Walmart can face crash liability after Montgomery's broker ruling.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- Elena Vasquez
- Filed
- Length
- 865 words
- Read
- 4 min

Key points05
- Supreme Court granted a GVR order Monday in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, sending the case back to a California appellate court
- Lower courts dismissed Walmart and Irigoyen in September 2023, affirmed September 2025; California Supreme Court denied review January 2026
- The crash near Fresno in September 2019 killed Olivia Mendoza; driver Andre Hill received a two-year sentence for vehicular manslaughter
- Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, decided in May, held brokers can be viewed under F4A as acting 'with respect to motor vehicles'
- Days after Montgomery, a Texas court rejected liability for Home Depot in a fatal Werner Enterprises wreck
The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday granted certiorari in Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, reviving a case that could determine whether shippers and freight receivers can be held liable for highway crashes in the post-Montgomery legal environment. The action came as a Grant, Vacate, Remand order — a procedural vehicle that sends the case back to a lower court without a ruling on the merits, while keeping the door open for the nine justices to take up the question later.
The case now returns to a California appellate court, which must reconsider whether a shipper or its customer can face liability arising from a crash. So far, the legal process in Casarez has firmly answered no to that question. But that record was built before Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II stripped away certain protections for brokers in May, opening the possibility that the new litigation landscape could eventually extend liability to shippers and their customers as well.
Who are the defendants?
The defendant list includes Walmart (NYSE: WMT). Irigoyen Farms was shipping produce from its operations in Selma, California, to a Walmart distribution center in Nevada.
The underlying crash occurred in September 2019 near Fresno. A truck driven by independent contractor Andre Hill, hauling Irigoyen produce to Walmart, went through a stop sign and struck the car of Olivia Mendoza, who died at the scene. The plaintiff, Casarez, is Mendoza's mother. Hill was ultimately sentenced to two years in prison after a vehicular manslaughter conviction.
The brokerage chain was layered. According to case briefs, Irigoyen contracted with Royal Violet Logistics, which contracted with SIO Logistics, which hired Gold Coast Logistics as carrier of the load. Gold Coast then hired Hill to move the freight. The outcome of any litigation against the 3PLs or the carrier was not immediately clear.
How did the lower courts rule?
Fresno County Superior Court granted summary judgment to Irigoyen and Walmart in September 2023, dismissing them from the lawsuit. The two companies argued that the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, with its prohibition on state actions affecting a "price, route or service," preempted claims against them.
They also contended that F4A's "safety exception," which permits tort actions arising from incidents like crashes, could not reach them because Walmart and Irigoyen were not "motor vehicles." The exception's wording limits its application "with respect to motor vehicles." The Fifth Appellate District of the California Court of Appeal affirmed the dismissal in September 2025, and the California Supreme Court denied review in January 2026.
Montgomery changed the calculus. By holding that broker actions can be viewed under F4A as being "with respect to motor vehicles," the decision undercut much of the rationale behind the two California rulings. Casarez then petitioned the Supreme Court, which granted the GVR on Monday. Without it, the case would have effectively ended in California, preserving a body of pre-Montgomery decisions favorable to shippers and receivers.
What does the ruling mean for shippers?
The industry debate now centers on whether "with respect to motor vehicles" can pull a shipper or freight receiver into a crash lawsuit. Shippers have so far prevailed since Montgomery: days after the May decision, a Texas court rejected liability for Home Depot (NYSE: HD) in a fatal wreck involving products hauled by Werner Enterprises (NASDAQ: WERN).
Walmart issued a brief statement on Monday's order. "(Monday's) order grants the relief Walmart asked for in its response to Ms. Casarez's petition," the company said. "We will continue to defend the company in the California Court of Appeal."
In its Supreme Court brief, Walmart sought to distance itself from the hiring chain. "As the intended recipient of the shipment, Walmart played no role in arranging for transportation," the company said. "Walmart did not select the broker, the motor carrier, or the driver. It did not provide or maintain the vehicle. Nor did it participate in any other way."
Gregory Reed, a partner at Hanson Bridgett who leads the firm's Transportation and Logistics practice group, called the case "the most important shipper-receiver liability case to watch right now" in an email. But he added that "it is unclear whether the door is open for a monumental ruling" like Montgomery's.
Reed noted the Supreme Court, for now, "passed on taking up the question that both Irigoyen Farm and (Casarez) requested: whether F4A preemption can be invoked by parties, such as shippers and receivers further up the supply chain, other than brokers and motor carriers as expressly enumerated in the statute." He also pointed out that no circuit court split currently exists on shipper/receiver liability — the kind of division that often prompts Supreme Court review, as it eventually did in Montgomery after earlier certiorari rejections piled up.
One factual distinction may matter on remand. Reed observed that Irigoyen — unlike Walmart — had driver Hill onsite where multiple witnesses said he appeared visibly fatigued, an issue that could weigh against the produce shipper but not the retailer. With the California appellate court set to rehear the case under Montgomery's shadow, shippers and receivers across the supply chain now face a reopened question that just months ago appeared settled in their favor.
Original: finance.yahoo.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
943 articles
Related05
Carriers' $150M RICO Threat Against TQL and C.H. Robinson Faces Long Odds
New Mexico Jury Hits Pilot Thomas Logistics With $47M Tanker Crash Verdict
Carriers Hit C.H. Robinson and TQL with RICO Suit in Texas
Shippers Turn to RICO Claims Against C.H. Robinson and TQL
Meyer Estate Tells Fifth Circuit: Penske En Banc Bid Doesn't Warrant Rehearing