WW/MARKETANAL

Filed 553W3M read

FTR Shippers Conditions Index falls to -17.3 in September

FTR's Shippers Conditions Index hit -17.3 in September, the second-worst reading since March 2022, as record diesel prices and rising capacity utilization point to firmer freight rates ahead.

By
James Calloway
Filed
Length
553 words
Read
3 min
FTR’s Shippers Conditions Index takes another backwards step
FTR’s Shippers Conditions Index takes another backwards stepEngin_Akyurt / pixabay

Key points05

  • FTR's Shippers Conditions Index fell to -17.3 in September from a revised -13.8 in August.
  • September tied April as the second-worst month since March 2022's -23.1; only March 2026 was worse at -18.9.
  • Record-high diesel prices drove the decline, alongside strongly negative capacity and rate components.
  • FTR raised its capacity utilization forecast on slow trucking payroll job growth, pointing to firmer rates.
  • FTR expects conditions to stay tougher than previously forecast for the next couple of quarters unless diesel surges again.

Freight market conditions for shippers deteriorated to a reading of -17.3 on FTR's Shippers Conditions Index in September, down from a revised -13.8 in August and -8.1 in July, according to the consultancy's latest edition of the index.

September matched April as the second-toughest month for shippers going back to March 2022's -23.1 reading, FTR said. Only one month in that span was worse: March 2026, at -18.9.

The index blends rates, capacity and fuel into a single gauge of freight market health from the shipper's side. Positive scores mean favorable conditions, with more carrier supply available. Negative readings signal tight capacity and tougher times for shippers. Readings near zero indicate a neutral market, and those can swing quickly on fuel price moves, regulatory changes or broader economic shifts.

FTR blamed September's slump on record-high diesel prices, compounded by capacity utilization and rate components that remained strongly negative. The firm also sharpened its near-term outlook: the market now looks more challenging for shippers over the next couple of quarters than it did in FTR's previous forecast.

What is driving the deterioration?

Avery Vise, FTR's vice president of trucking, pointed first at the fuel pump.

"The surge in fuel prices to an all-time high in September guaranteed a highly unfavorable market for shippers," Vise said. "Although diesel prices are easing – at least for now – dynamics related to the freight market remain quite challenging and look to be even tougher for shippers than previously estimated."

The capacity side of the equation is tightening for a structural reason: hiring has stalled. Slow payroll job growth in trucking and other factors have led FTR to raise its expectations for capacity utilization over the next couple of quarters, Vise said, which in turn points to firmer freight rates ahead.

There is one caveat, and it comes with a condition attached.

"The good news is that the overall market conditions do not look to be as difficult for shippers as they were in September – provided, of course, that diesel prices do not surge again," Vise said.

What should shippers watch next?

The trajectory of the index matters as much as any single print. The slide from -8.1 in July to -17.3 in September marks three consecutive months of worsening conditions, and FTR's revised forecast implies no quick relief through the next two quarters.

For shippers, the practical consequences are straightforward. Firmer rates mean budgeting for contract renewals and spot exposure on tighter terms than a year of soft readings suggested. Rising capacity utilization means fewer options when freight surges, and potential bottlenecks on lanes where carriers can be pickier about loads. Fuel, the most volatile component in the index, remains the wildcard: September proved how quickly an all-time diesel high can drag the whole reading into the worst territory since early 2022.

FTR advises shippers to monitor the trend closely rather than any single monthly figure, given how readily readings fluctuate with fuel prices and economic shifts. With diesel now easing but utilization expected to climb, the balance of pressure is shifting from the pump to the capacity side of the index — and toward rate negotiations that favor carriers more than at any point since the market last turned.

Source: logisticsmgmt.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

992 articles

Related05

  1. Record diesel sinks FTR shipper index to -17.3 in September

  2. FTR Trucking Conditions Index Slips to 8.13 as Record Fuel Costs Bite

  3. Flatbed Spot Rates Post Biggest Weekly Drop Since August

  4. Fuel prices now rank as trucking's number-one worry, Morningstar finds

  5. Capacity Contracts for 11th Month as Spot Rates Jump 47%

« Prev