WW/TRUCKINGRA
FMCSA revoked 133 ELDs; ATA proposes permanent fraud safeguards
FMCSA has revoked 133 ELDs and nearly 300 since the Trump administration began. ATA wants third-party certification, tighter lifecycle checks and faster fraud screening.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- Elena Vasquez
- Filed
- Length
- 943 words
- Read
- 5 min

Key points05
- FMCSA revoked authorization for 133 electronic logging devices last week.
- Almost 300 devices have been revoked since the Trump administration took office, versus fewer than 200 during four years under Biden.
- ATA's task force included 25 members from member companies, plus ATA employees.
- A 2022 FMCSA ANPRM drew 1,377 comments but resulted in no policy changes.
- ATA proposes Canadian-style third-party certification and a possible conversion of the 2022 ANPRM into an NPRM.
By Elena Vasquez
FMCSA revoked the authorization of 133 electronic logging devices last week, part of almost 300 revocations since the Trump administration took office, according to an FMCSA downloadable Excel file. During the four years of the Biden administration, the agency recorded fewer than 200 revocations.
Kevin Grove, ATA's director of safety and technology policy, described a fraud pattern involving a driver who reaches the hours-of-service limit. The driver then receives a phone number and uses wireless communication to upload new logs showing more available hours.
“They can call the number, and then through wireless communication, they’re able to upload new logs to the device that essentially shows the driver has more hours of service available,” Grove said. The records may appear spotless to an inspector, he said, while fuel receipts and bills of lading can tell a different story.
For carriers, fraudulent logs can make hours-of-service compliance look sound when it is not, exposing a fleet to scrutiny during inspections. For shippers and freight forwarders, mismatched fuel purchases or bills of lading can undermine confidence in the records supporting a shipment.
What is driving the ELD revocations?
ATA released its roadmap earlier this week. Its internal task force included 25 members from ATA member companies, plus ATA employees.
The report seeks to restore trust immediately in the ELD ecosystem and maintain it over the long term, including through federal databases of ELD providers.
The revocations come against a backdrop of self-certification, in which ELD companies meet requirements supplied by FMCSA. FMCSA has recently begun scrutinizing submissions more closely than in the past, while ATA wants a durable system after the current administration's aggressive enforcement phase.
ATA frames the next step around what happens after Trump officials' revocations run their course. The task force's stated goal is to restore confidence in electronic records while preventing the devices from remaining useful tools for fraudulent activity.
What would third-party certification change?
Rather than create an entirely new model, ATA says FMCSA should build on existing certification mechanisms. It identifies Canada's framework as a useful model for incorporating independent technical expertise into an effective certification regime.
The proposed U.S. program would be administered separately from Canada's and tailored to the U.S. regulatory environment. Regulators should align technical requirements and testing approaches whenever possible, preserving common ground without merging the systems.
Once the certification program is in place, ATA wants FMCSA to turn to an outside entity to accredit ELDs regularly. FMCSA should fund development of the accreditation program that supports third-party certification.
“Under this approach, FMCSA would retain responsibility for establishing and maintaining the technical requirements, resolving questions of regulatory interpretation, and conducting investigation and enforcement activities, while qualified third-party organization(s) would administer accreditation and certification,” the ATA said. The division would let the agency focus on regulation while drawing on outside technical expertise.
If adopted, independent accreditation would give shippers, carriers and freight forwarders a more credible basis for checking electronic hours records against supporting documents. For carriers, the proposed transition matters because existing ELDs would need certification before any new requirements take effect.
The ATA report sets no cost estimate or implementation deadline for the third-party regime. That leaves shippers and forwarders without figures for pricing compliance changes, while carriers still face uncertainty about when current devices must meet the new rules.
Can FMCSA fight fraud before new rules take effect?
ATA wants FMCSA to address known fraud methods in the existing system immediately, without waiting for rulemaking. The goal is to turn the ELD from a device scammers can exploit into an ally against freight fraud.
ATA identifies three warning signs in electronic records of duty status, or ERODS:
- Out-of-sequence file numbers
- Impossible distances
- Driver information manipulation
The report also calls for more touch points involving devices and suppliers. No single touch point would catch all fraud, but greater breadth and frequency would improve detection and shorten the time available to scammers. Certification also cannot end when a device receives approval, because it must be maintained throughout the equipment lifecycle.
What happens to the 2022 proposal?
FMCSA's 2022 advance notice of proposed rulemaking on possible ELD revisions drew 1,377 comments but produced no policy shift. ATA says those comments and other recommendations could provide the foundation for a revised governance framework.
The ANPRM could become a formal notice of proposed rulemaking, or NPRM. During that stage, FMCSA could gauge interest among prospective accreditation and certification providers and assess their capacity and requirements for joining the program.
During the NPRM, ATA says FMCSA can concurrently develop a final-rule compliance timeline. That timeline should provide enough time to establish the accreditation system and certify existing ELDs before new requirements take effect.
For carriers, sufficient lead time would reduce the risk of an abrupt compliance gap during the handover to certified devices. For shippers and freight forwarders, more frequent device and supplier checks would improve the odds of detecting manipulated logs before shipment records are trusted.
Neither shippers nor forwarders receives a guaranteed cost or timetable from the roadmap. The current enforcement campaign can remove suspect devices, but the permanent framework still depends on an NPRM, a final rule and the creation of qualified third-party administrators.
Where is the policy trajectory heading?
If FMCSA follows the ATA roadmap, the next policy test is whether the 2022 ANPRM advances into an NPRM and produces a funded third-party certification program. Until that process establishes dates, costs and certified capacity, revocations and stricter ELD checks are likely to remain the main enforcement tools.
Original: getfreightdata.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
956 articles
Related05
FMCSA Pulls 133 ELDs From Registry in Hours-of-Service Fraud Crackdown
FMCSA Yanks 133 ELDs From Registry Over Falsified Driver Logs
FMCSA Rejects Bid to Bring Back Paper Logbooks for Truckers
ATA Charts Six-Step Roadmap to Combat ELD Fraud in Trucking
FMCSA denies truckers' bid to swap ELDs for paper logbooks