WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 976W5M read

Cargo theft losses more than double to $304.6M as thieves shift targets

Cargo theft losses hit $304.6M in Q2 2026, double a year earlier, on 26% fewer incidents. E3 Group's CEO says fictitious pickups of GPU loads are beating carrier vetting.

By
James Calloway
Filed
Length
976 words
Read
5 min
Good Carriers, Wrong Drivers: Why Cargo Theft Is Moving Past Carrier Vetting
Good Carriers, Wrong Drivers: Why Cargo Theft Is Moving Past Carrier Vettinganiset / pixabay

Key points05

  • Q2 2026 cargo theft losses reached $304.6M, up from $135.7M a year earlier, while incidents fell 26% to 677 (Verisk CargoNet).
  • E3 CEO Aqil Naeem says some customers lose over $50M a year unreported, and fictitious pickup is '100% on the rise.'
  • Roughly 92% of stolen high-tech equipment involves fictitious pickups; single $40M GPU loads have been reported.
  • E3 verifies 6,000+ drivers daily and over 800,000 loads with zero cargo thefts, at a 96% seamless completion rate.
  • Pickup codes for enterprise shippers trade on black markets for $5,000–$10,000, Naeem said.

Cargo theft losses hit an estimated $304.6 million in the second quarter of 2026, more than double the $135.7 million recorded a year earlier, even as reported incidents fell 26% to 677, according to Verisk CargoNet. Fewer thefts. Much bigger checks.

The gap between reported and real losses is wider still, according to Aqil Naeem, co-founder and CEO of driver verification platform E3 Group, who spoke in an FWTV interview at FreightWaves F3. "We have customers of ours that are losing over $50 million a year in cargo losses, they're just not reporting it," Naeem said.

Reputation drives the silence. "When you're a shipper and you're losing cargo, that looks bad for your brand," he said. When he asks E3's customers whether they share data with CargoNet, "a lot of them just opt out of it."

What's driving the loss totals?

Fictitious pickup and strategic deception top the list. Naeem was unequivocal: "Amongst my customer base, fictitious pickup and deception are 100% on the rise."

Reported fictitious-pickup counts have been roughly flat, moving from 165 to 158 year over year in the data discussed in the interview. The cost per incident has climbed. Naeem attributes that to targeting, not inflation: criminals are passing on low-value freight in favor of high-value loads, particularly data center moves.

He cited a statistic that roughly 92% of stolen high-tech equipment involves fictitious pickups and deception. Single losses can be enormous. Journalists have contacted him about $40 million GPU loads — one of which alone would account for more than 10% of the quarterly total.

Why doesn't carrier vetting catch it?

The paperwork holds up. Naeem described a pattern in which criminals use a valid carrier's credentials to pass onboarding, then send someone else to the gate. "Everything checks out," he said. "There might be someone on the inside who shares a pickup number, and the person who actually comes to the gate is different."

His review of customer thefts found a consistent pattern. "I haven't seen a single cargo theft happen with an MC that would have failed a carrier vetting solution," Naeem said. "The real problem is that people are working with good carriers. But information is leaking."

That information has a market. Naeem described black markets where pickup codes for large enterprise shippers trade openly. "For $5,000, $10,000, you can go ahead and buy a pickup code, the appointment, and the information you need," he said. "You buy a magnet, you impersonate a carrier, and there's nothing stopping you from picking up that freight."

Business email compromise remains a common entry point, but Naeem framed it as a symptom, not the root cause. A breached inbox gives a criminal visibility into pickup codes and times. He called it "more of a logistics question" and would not treat email security as the ultimate fix.

Where does verification move?

Naeem's diagnosis shapes E3's product: confirming at the gate that the arriving driver is actually affiliated with the carrier the broker booked. "Increasingly, carrier vetting is starting to become not only commoditized but ineffective," he said. "You're essentially doing LLC verification. The person who comes can be completely different."

Customers have invested heavily in vetting, he said, and "they just have not seen cargo thefts decline." He doesn't know "a single top 25 brokerage" that has seen thefts fall over the past two years.

E3 unifies information from three parties — broker, driver and shipper — so the shipper confirms the driver at the gate was dispatched by that broker. Naeem said E3 verifies more than 6,000 drivers per day and has verified over 800,000 loads without a single cargo theft incident.

What about driver friction and data?

E3 reports a 96% seamless completion rate. "Arguably the most important factor when it comes to driver verification" is driver completion, Naeem said. The 4% who drop out are revealing: drivers masking their IP who refuse to turn off a VPN, and drivers unwilling to photograph their CDL. "Obviously, someone who is fraudulent is not going to try to attempt to get through a verification process," he said.

E3 positions itself as driver-centric. Naeem said he discusses the product on SiriusXM and gets "dozens of emails weekly from drivers thanking us for the product."

On deterrence, Naeem said verification builds a full identity profile — name, vehicle, VIN, potentially ELD connections, home address. "You are essentially taking on the biggest gamble of your life if you try to steal a load from one of our customers," he said.

On data custody, customers set their own exposure. Some "will not want us to show them the CDL at all," while others "want us to store it in their Snowflake DB, and they want the custody of that data." His advice to brokers: stop hoarding CDLs. "I know brokers that have 1000s of CDLs that they have never deleted" — $1,000 fines waiting to be claimed.

On liability, E3 refunds its fees if an authenticated load is stolen, with insurance holding the cargo loss. "Cargo loss has not happened yet on our platform," Naeem said, adding that customers can "just text me, and I'll cover the deductible." For misdirection after pickup, drivers confirm their destination; a changed location triggers a flagged risk incident, escalation and removal from the load.

Naeem closed with a warning grounded in litigation: Hardy v. Singh, where parties were found liable for failing to check double brokering, and a suit he said C.H. Robinson and Unilever currently face. "It's not just a cargo theft question now; it's becoming a liability question," he said. As losses double despite stronger vetting, expect more shippers and brokers to move the control point from the MC number to the gate.

Original: verisk.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

992 articles

Related05

  1. Cargo theft costs 28% of shippers over $2M annually: SmartSense

  2. Cargo Theft Falls 33% in Q3, but Losses Hit $230.1 Million

  3. Cargo theft falls 26% but losses double to $304.6 million in Q2

  4. Cargo theft survey finds security gaps as identity fraud climbs

  5. Cargo Theft Incidents Fall 25%, But Losses Jump 39% to $718.9m

« PrevNext »