WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 844W4M read

BNSF, J.B. Hunt and corn growers line up against $85bn UP-NS merger

BNSF found 310-plus errors in UP-NS traffic analysis; J.B. Hunt, corn growers and FRCA oppose the $85bn merger, saying protections cover just 0.9% of rail traffic.

By
Amara Osei
Filed
Length
844 words
Read
4 min
Competition, service disruptions and higher costs lead opposition to proposed UP-NS merger in STB filings
Competition, service disruptions and higher costs lead opposition to proposed UP-NS merger in STB filingsKIMDAEJEUNG / pixabay

Key points05

  • Filings to the STB opposing the $85bn UP-NS merger closed November 18.
  • BNSF identified over 310 errors in the merger traffic analysis; proposed pricing protections cover 0.9% of rail traffic.
  • Unions representing over 70% of the combined workforce and shipper groups covering over 50% of rail cargo oppose or question the deal.
  • UP and NS claim the merger removes 2.1 million trucks from roads and saves shippers $3.5bn annually.
  • The merger would span 50,000+ route miles across 43 states and about 100 ports.

Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern's proposed $85 billion merger drew near-uniform opposition in filings to the Surface Transportation Board, with BNSF flagging more than 310 errors in the applicants' traffic analysis and J.B. Hunt calling the deal likely to harm intermodal customers more than help them.

The STB, Congress's adjudicatory body for railroad rate and service disputes and merger review, set November 18 as the deadline for comments, protests and requests for conditions on the revised merger application. Almost nobody filing used the opportunity to cheer.

Announced in July 2025, the merger would create the country's first transcontinental railroad — more than 50,000 route miles across 43 states, linking roughly 100 ports from the East Coast to the West. That scale is precisely the problem, according to competing railroads, shipper groups, labor unions, farmers and several state governors and attorneys general. Their core arguments: nearly half of all U.S. rail traffic would sit under one carrier; competitive options that keep rates and service in check would vanish; integrating two large networks running different systems invites service disruption; and consumers, farmers, manufacturers, energy producers and rail-served communities would all pay for it.

What do the carriers themselves say?

UP and NS argue the opposite. They contend the merger makes rail "significantly more competitive with long-haul trucking," pulling about 2.1 million trucks off the road — roughly a fleet the size of a mid-sized national truckload market — and saving shippers an estimated $3.5 billion a year. Those savings, they say, would flow through to consumer prices while faster, more reliable single-line service cuts inventory and equipment costs.

BNSF isn't buying it. Its filing identified more than 310 errors and corrections in the UP-NS traffic analysis, questioned the projected growth, and noted that the applicants' proposed pricing protections would cover just 0.9% of rail traffic. It also pointed out that shipper groups representing more than 50% of rail cargo have opposed or raised concerns, and unions representing more than 70% of the combined workforce are against the deal.

CPKC took a narrower line. It warned the merger could weaken its ability to compete in the Chicago-Detroit corridor and asked the STB for protective conditions preserving its existing access and expanding its operating rights.

Farmers and shippers want proof, not promises

The National Corn Growers Association set out its terms plainly: it supports consolidation only when transactions enhance competitive service, protect rates and routing options, and show no net negative impact on agricultural transportation costs or reliability. "On the current record, applicants have not demonstrated that this transaction meets those tests," the group said.

NCGA also delivered the quote that will likely haunt the applicants' service commitments: "UP and NS use different operating models, and no previous Class I merger has been integrated without significant service disruption. Any disruptions to the freight system, whether caused by operational misalignments, infrastructure closures, or labor shortages, can cause immediate risks to U.S. farmers."

The Freight Rail Customer Alliance went furthest, demanding outright denial. Under the STB's merger rules revised in 2001, applicants must show a deal enhances competition, ensures reliable service and serves the public interest. FRCA argued concentration will do the opposite, blaming the industry's high rates, shrinking volumes and poor service on the concentration that followed the 1990s Class I consolidation round. "There is no good basis to think that the Applicants' proposed merger will reverse these trends and strong reason to conclude it will make them worse," FRCA said, adding that the merger "is not necessary to achieve the claimed service benefits."

The intermodal verdict

J.B. Hunt, which moves around 2.25 million loads by rail annually from its Lowell, Ark. base, was blunt: the merger "would likely result in more harm than benefit to the intermodal customers it serves." The company said the application's highway-conversion projections don't match its own real-world experience, and that intermodal shippers get no assurance the promised benefits would reach them or that UP-NS would face accountability for missed service levels.

"Severe service disruptions" followed every major rail merger the Board approved, J.B. Hunt noted — disruptions that would undermine the very reliability that drives shippers off the highway. It also warned the deal could trigger further Class I consolidation, concentrating market power further.

Tony Hatch, principal of New York-based ABH Consulting, said rival railroads are playing this smartly: watching the process and extracting benefits — access, for instance — without risking anything. "If this merger is approved and creates a superpower that will hurt them, other railroads will merge and they will know how to do it, because right now UP is sailing in the dark on its own," he said, adding that the STB decision is "the most important decision in the 200-year history of the industry because it will have follow-on effects."

The Board's review, and the 0.9% protections question, now sit at the center of what happens to North American rail competition.

Source: logisticsmgmt.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

992 articles

Related05

  1. Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger divides rail leaders

  2. Union Pacific CEO '99.99%' Sure STB Clears $85bn NS Deal

  3. UP-NS merger would hand one railroad 50% of the US market

  4. Schneider to switch eastern rail partner to Norfolk Southern on Jan. 1

  5. BNSF Fires Back at UP-NS Merger With 130-Exhibit STB Filing

« PrevNext »