WW/TRUCKINGRA
BNSF Fires Back at UP-NS Merger With 130-Exhibit STB Filing
BNSF filed formal opposition to the Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger with the STB on November 18, backed by 130-plus exhibits and claims of 310 errors in the applicants' traffic analysis.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- James Calloway
- Filed
- Length
- 564 words
- Read
- 3 min

Key points05
- BNSF filed its merger opposition with the STB on November 18, supported by more than 130 exhibits.
- BNSF identified over 310 errors in UP/NS's traffic analysis.
- The proposed Committed Gateway Pricing program would cover just 0.9% of rail traffic.
- Shipper groups representing more than 50% of rail cargo oppose or have concerns; unions covering 70% of the combined workforce oppose.
- BNSF previously outlined merger conditions in a September 9 STB filing.
BNSF has formally asked the Surface Transportation Board to block the Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger, filing a brief on November 18 backed by more than 130 exhibits, declarations from BNSF executives, expert witnesses and extensive supporting data.
The filing is BNSF's most detailed case yet against the transaction. Its public summary argues the merger would harm competition, raise costs for shippers, and fail to deliver the benefits UP and NS have promised regulators and customers.
"UP will be UP — with more market power," the brief argues.
What does the filing actually claim?
BNSF's opposition rests on three concrete lines of attack:
- Flawed traffic projections. BNSF identifies more than 310 errors and corrections in UP/NS's traffic analysis, which it says calls into question the merger's projected truck-to-rail traffic gains — the core of the applicants' growth case.
- Thin shipper protections. BNSF argues the Committed Gateway Pricing program proposed by UP and NS would cover just 0.9% of rail traffic, a fraction of the market the carriers present as a competitive safeguard.
- Broad opposition. "Shipper groups representing more than 50% of rail cargo have opposed or raised concerns about the merger, while unions representing more than 70% of the projected combined unionized workforce oppose it," the filing said.
The November 18 submission builds on an earlier move. On September 9, BNSF filed with the STB outlining the conditions it would seek to protect competition if the merger wins approval. The new filing goes further: it formally presents BNSF's opposition, backed by evidence, expert testimony and analysis, and makes a more detailed argument that the deal is not in the public interest.
Why the stakes reach beyond BNSF
The STB has already declined to kill the proposal outright, rejecting earlier petitions to deny the UP/Norfolk merger application and allowing the review process to continue. Opponents keep coming anyway. A farmers' union has separately pushed back against the rail mega-merger, joining the shipper coalitions BNSF cites in its filing.
For shippers, the commercial consequences are straightforward. A combined UP-NS would create a single transcontinental railroad spanning the West and East coasts, and BNSF — itself the largest Western carrier — claims the merged entity would hold enough route and pricing power to squeeze freight costs across corridors where alternatives are limited. The 0.9% figure is BNSF's way of saying the carriers' voluntary pricing commitments leave the overwhelming share of traffic unprotected.
For UP and NS, the filing raises the evidentiary bar. More than 300 identified errors in a traffic study hands the STB's reviewers a ready-made line of questioning on whether the projected truck-to-rail diversion — a key public-benefit claim — survives scrutiny.
BNSF is one of six major Class I freight railroads — carriers with annual operating revenues exceeding $1 billion — serving the U.S. market. The others are CSX Transportation, Canadian National Railway (CN) and CPKC Railway, alongside the two merger applicants themselves. A UP-NS combination would cut that field to five and redraw the Class I map for the first time since CPKC's 2023 formation.
The STB's review now carries a heavier record: two BNSF filings, organized shipper and labor opposition, and a contested traffic model. How the board weighs the 310-error challenge against the applicants' benefit projections will shape whether the merger clears its final hurdle.
Source: supplychainbrain.com
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
948 articles
Related05
Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger divides rail leaders
UP-NS merger would hand one railroad 50% of the US market
Union Pacific CEO '99.99%' Sure STB Clears $85bn NS Deal
Schneider to switch eastern rail partner to Norfolk Southern on Jan. 1
STB rejects Union Pacific appeal, orders Vena speech video public