WW/SUPPLYCHAI

Filed 690W3M read

81% of Logistics AI Projects Fail on Workflow Redesign Gap

A study of ~200 logistics leaders finds 81% of AI projects fail: 69% of firms use AI beyond pilots, but only 19% have redesigned workflows — leaving 30% with below-par returns.

By
Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
690 words
Read
3 min
AI for Logistics: Why 81% of AI Projects Fail
AI for Logistics: Why 81% of AI Projects FailTama66 / pixabay

Key points04

  • 81% of logistics AI projects fail; only 19% of firms have redesigned workflows though 69% moved past isolated AI use.
  • 30% of AI adopters reported below-expectation returns; 72% of logistics decisions remain human-led.
  • One client automated 71% of invoices with AI, saving 640 hours; another cut route-deviation response times by 77%.
  • Emails are 90% AI-handled at some clients; carrier sales and customer sales are flagged as high-risk for full automation.

Eighty-one percent of AI projects in logistics fail, and the research behind that figure points to one structural cause: companies buy the technology but skip the organizational transformation it depends on. A study by Lean Solutions Group and Everest Group, based on interviews with roughly 200 industry leaders, found that 69% of companies have moved past isolated AI use — yet only 19% have redesigned their workflows to match.

That 50-point gap between adoption and redesign is driving widespread underperformance across carriers, brokers and third-party logistics providers. In a 5% margin business like freight brokerage, the cost of a failed implementation is not abstract: 30% of respondents reported below-expectation returns on their AI investments, according to Jack Freker, CEO of Lean Solutions Group.

"They've applied technology, but they haven't gone deep into the fit and readiness of the organization — in terms of which are the appropriate functions for AI transformation, which are the tasks that need experts in the loop and humans in the loop to complete the task to gain real benefits here," Freker said.

Many of the firms reporting disappointing returns lack the internal consulting bench to manage a full transformation, he noted. The result is a cycle: they churn through three or four technology vendors with little to show for it.

What should be automated first?

The study found that 72% of logistics decisions remain human-led, and Freker drew a sharp line between what belongs on each side of it. Back-office functions show the strongest measurable results. Accounts payable invoice processing and track-and-trace are already delivering: at one client, 71% of invoices are completed entirely by AI, saving 640 hours of manual labor that staff have redeployed to higher-value work.

The track-and-trace numbers are similarly concrete. One 130-person team now tracks 54,000 loads. Another client layered AI onto a team of roughly 50 people monitoring high-value loads and cut route-deviation response times by 77% — enough to remove 15 to 20 headcount from that function.

Email handling has reached 90% AI completion for some clients, and Freker flagged invoice matching, proof-of-delivery, payment collections, appointment scheduling and quote responses as well-suited to full automation because they are repeatable and low-risk.

Where does AI still need humans?

Carrier sales and customer sales are the exception. Because those functions run on relationships and judgment, Freker said, AI should augment rather than replace the people doing them — and companies need to treat them more carefully in any transformation plan.

"They've got to take the step first to redesign, create new processes, and then determine which are the processes that still need humans, still need judgment, still need relationships — which are the processes that are maybe lower value, that are more repeatable, that can be automated in a fairly easy and low-risk manner," Freker said.

The sequencing matters commercially. Brokers and forwarders that automate high-volume, low-risk tasks first can bank the hours saved while protecting the revenue-generating functions where judgment still carries margin.

An 'Iron Man suit' for agents

Lean Solutions Group, which Freker said has operated for 14 years and now works across six countries following recent acquisitions, has built its own answer to the redesign problem. Its product, Decision Intelligence, connects to client systems in one click and equips individual agents with what Freker described as an "Iron Man suit" — a tool layer that clears away rote tasks so staff can raise the number of customer and carrier contacts made per day.

The company positions itself as an expert-in-the-loop alternative for brokers and logistics firms that have already tried pure technology plays and come up short. The pitch targets precisely the 30% of adopters reporting sub-par returns: augment the people, redesign the process, then automate what remains.

For an industry where nearly three-quarters of decisions still run through human judgment, the study's trajectory is clear — the next wave of AI gains in logistics will come less from new models and more from the unglamorous work of rebuilding workflows around them.

Original: getfreightdata.com

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

956 articles

Related05

  1. 69% of firms deploy AI at scale, only 19% redesign work

  2. 83% of supply chain leaders say their workforce can't use AI

  3. 90% of warehouse operators plan more AI spend, but ROI proof lags

  4. 57% expect autonomous AI for over a quarter of warehouse decisions

  5. Just 18% see better customer experience from port AI, BCG study finds

« PrevNext »