WW/PORTSTERMI

Filed 536W3M read

Just 18% see better customer experience from port AI, BCG study finds

Only 18% of port industry experts report improved customer experience from AI, a BCG/TIC4.0 survey of 103 respondents finds, even as China launches 22 AI projects across its ports.

By
James Calloway
Filed
Length
536 words
Read
3 min
AI commercial returns questioned…
AI commercial returns questioned…cegoh / pixabay

Key points05

  • Only 18% of 103 surveyed port industry experts say AI has improved customer experience (BCG/TIC4.0).
  • 41% cite uncertain ROI as the biggest obstacle to AI adoption; 62% use or explore AI for shipping document processing.
  • China's Ministry of Transport has launched 22 AI port and maritime projects: nine safety, ten efficiency, three decarbonisation.
  • Ningbo-Zhoushan's AI platform cut cargo preparation times 50% and order processing times 66%, Beijing claims.
  • SIPG reports equipment fault-finding resolution times down 20% on average from AI deployment.

Only 18% of port industry respondents say AI deployment has improved customer experience, according to new research from Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and the Terminal Industry Committee 4.0 (TIC4.0) — a figure that suggests the technology is delivering value mainly inside terminal operations rather than for the shippers and carriers they serve.

The study drew on responses from 103 industry experts worldwide. Its headline conclusion: the gap between AI adoption and commercial returns is widening. Some 44% of companies confirmed they are developing or scaling AI applications, or moving to more advanced deployment stages. Yet the payoff remains elusive for most.

Uncertainty is measurable. Concerns over uncertain returns on investment were cited by 41% of respondents as the biggest obstacle to greater AI use. Data quality worries followed at 32%, and questions over systems integration totalled 30%.

Where is AI actually working in terminals?

The study acknowledged that AI is already live across terminal operations. The most common use cases:

  • Shipping document processing
  • Predictive crane maintenance
  • Cargo planning
  • Equipment dispatch

The document side leads by a wide margin. Some 62% of responding companies confirmed they use or are exploring AI to extract information from shipping documents. Predictive maintenance applications came in at 48%.

Downstream players are moving faster than terminals in some respects. Greater use of AI by freight forwarders was cited by 61% of replies, with logistics service providers at 52%.

The commercial read for operators is straightforward. AI is currently an internal-efficiency play — maintenance windows, document flows, dispatch decisions — not yet a customer-facing differentiator. Terminals investing on the expectation of shipper-visible service gains have little evidence to point to so far, and the 41% ROI scepticism rate reflects that.

What is China doing about it?

Beijing is pushing hard in the opposite direction of hesitation. China's Ministry of Transport has confirmed a new programme of 22 AI project applications across its port and maritime transport network, with defined priorities: nine applications focused on safety, 10 on operational efficiency and three specifically targeting decarbonisation.

The government claims concrete results at Ningbo-Zhoushan. An AI logistics optimisation platform there has cut cargo preparation times for customers by 50%, reduced order processing times by 66% and lowered average transport costs by 6.7%, according to Beijing's figures.

Shanghai offers a second data point. Operator Shanghai International Port Group (SIPG) says equipment fault-finding resolution times have fallen by an average of 20% thanks to AI deployment, and it has introduced AI-assisted systems across four functions: crane maintenance, container stowage planning, safety management and operational reporting.

SIPG plans to extend similar AI technology to older terminals throughout the port — a retrofit signal worth watching, since legacy infrastructure is where most of the global terminal fleet sits.

What happens next?

The contrast is stark. Chinese state-backed deployment comes with claimed, quantified benefits — halved preparation times, a fifth off fault-resolution times — while the global survey population still cannot tie AI spending to customer outcomes, and 41% of experts flag uncertain returns as the top barrier. If China's claimed numbers hold up, expect pressure on terminal operators elsewhere to move beyond pilot-stage document processing toward measurable, shipper-visible efficiency gains.

Source: portstrategy.com

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

921 articles

Related05

  1. AI scales at ports, but just 4% report earnings gains

  2. 90% of warehouse operators plan more AI spend, but ROI proof lags

  3. AI Adoption at Canadian Fleets Climbs to 49% in Two Years

  4. 83% of supply chain leaders say their workforce can't use AI

  5. AI to Orchestrate Procurement in 30% of Firms by 2030, Gartner Says

« PrevNext »