WW/SUPPLYCHAI
200 Studies, Six Questions: The Case Against One More Dashboard
Analysis of 200-plus studies yields the 6Ws Framework: six design questions meant to fix measurement systems, not add KPIs. Stockouts are the stress test.
- By
- Amara Osei
- Filed
- Length
- 654 words
- Read
- 3 min

Key points04
- The 6Ws Framework comes from analysis of more than 200 supply chain performance measurement studies
- It poses six design questions: why, what, where, when, who and which tools
- It is not intended to replace SCOR or the Balanced Scorecard, but to structure their coherent use
- It is illustrated through recurring stockouts during promotional activity
By Amara Osei
An analysis of more than 200 supply chain performance measurement studies has produced a framework built on six questions — and not one of them is "which KPI should we add?" The research, led by Dr. Stephen Kelly of the University of Salford, lands on an uncomfortable truth: most organizations don't suffer from too few metrics. They suffer from too many.
The finding sits awkwardly with industry orthodoxy. Dashboards, KPIs and analytics platforms are abundant. Yet, as the research notes, measures sometimes conflict, and despite the familiar belief that what gets measured gets managed, decision-making is often poorly connected to the information being generated.
What does the 6Ws Framework actually ask?
The structured analysis of those 200-plus studies identified six recurring dimensions, packaged as the 6Ws Framework:
- Why are we measuring?
- What should we measure?
- Where should measurement take place?
- When should measurement occur?
- Who should be involved?
- Which tools should be used?
The point, Kelly argues, isn't to replace SCOR or the Balanced Scorecard — both remain, in his words, readily available and well-established. The 6Ws provide a common language for designing the system as a whole, rather than bolting individual KPIs onto it in isolation.
Existing approaches share part of the blame. The research observes that SCOR, the Balanced Scorecard, artificial intelligence, predictive analytics and digital dashboards each focus on particular aspects of measurement rather than the design of the overall system. Valuable guidance, yes. Coherence check, no.
A stress test with stockouts
The framework gets practical with a familiar scenario: recurring stockouts during promotional activity. The traditional response is to hold more inventory and stack more KPIs onto existing dashboards. The 6Ws suggest stepping back first.
Take the six questions in order. On why: the goals might be reducing lost sales, improving product availability and protecting margins — not simply generating additional data. On what: forecast accuracy, case-fill rates and on-shelf availability, in a balanced set of hard and soft indicators.
The where question cuts deepest. A stockout visible to a customer may originate with poor supplier performance, production scheduling, inventory imbalances or weak retailer forecasting. Measurement should therefore extend across demand planning, production, distribution centers, suppliers — and possibly customers. That improves visibility of where problems originate, not merely where they surface.
On when: many organizations rely on historical reporting and discover problems only after they've damaged performance. Measuring during forecasting, production planning, promotional execution and post-event reviews catches emerging issues before shelves go empty.
Who's accountable, and with what?
Technology alone won't fix it. The research highlights leadership, decision-making, communication, relationship management and analytical skills as individual and organizational capabilities. Responsibility shouldn't sit exclusively with inventory planners: demand planners, supplier managers, S&OP teams, logistics specialists and senior managers all shape outcomes.
The final question — which tools — gets a dry verdict. Forecasting software, ERP systems, SCOR-based process measures, dashboards and AI-enabled planning all qualify. But organizations often obsess over tool selection while underinvesting in objectives, processes and capabilities. The best solution isn't the most sophisticated one. It's the one that fits the operating context.
What does this change for shippers?
The framework's core claim is that the six dimensions influence one another. Ambitious objectives without the capabilities or infrastructure to support them produce frustration. Measures are often ineffective when visibility or timing is poorly designed. Stockouts, the research concludes, rarely result from a single metric failure — they reflect a combination of strategic intent, visibility, timing, capabilities and tools.
The practical takeaways are blunt. Define success before selecting measures. Extend visibility beyond organizational boundaries. And ensure technology supports the measurement approach rather than driving it — even the most sophisticated dashboard adds little if objectives, capabilities and responsibilities remain unclear.
For supply chain managers weighing yet another analytics purchase, the framework offers a cheaper first step: six questions, asked before the procurement cycle starts.
Source: scmr.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
950 articles
Related05
Avianca Cargo and Kuehne+Nagel take Cargo iQ Quality Rally in Frankfurt
Vietnam's 13th Mekong-Japan Summit Sets Supply Chain Agenda
North American factories reset supply networks for resilience in 2026
AYK wins 165 MWh order for Molslinjen electric ferries
SEVOS Told a Client to Cut Three of 20 Roles Before Automating Anything