WW/MARKETANAL
Shippers Rebuild Carrier Ties as Rising Rates End Three-Year Freight Bargain
Rates have climbed sharply in six months, and NFI's Chuck Papa says spot-market shippers are 'paying the price' as 2027 planning forces supply chain redesign.
- Desk
- Rates & Markets
- By
- Elena Vasquez
- Filed
- Length
- 862 words
- Read
- 4 min

Key points05
- Transportation rates have risen dramatically over the past six months, NFI's Chuck Papa said.
- Shippers that relied on the spot market 'are now paying the price' as capacity tightens.
- NFI embedded AI into its Vantage control tower to run continuous network design instead of annual studies.
- NFI caps carrier payment terms at 30 days and warns against spreading volume across too many carriers.
- Papa recommends shippers build carrier relationships and 'look beyond the dock' for 2027 planning.
Transportation rates have risen "dramatically" over the past six months, ending a three-year window in which shippers could lean on a cheap spot market and defer hard questions about network design. Chuck Papa, president of transportation management at NFI, said the shift has pushed freight spending back in front of board-level executives — and forced a supply chain conversation that goes well beyond the freight bill.
Papa, who has spent roughly 30 years in the industry, said geopolitical turbulence makes this cycle unique. It has been "the biggest roller coaster of impact we've probably seen since the 30 years I've been doing this," he said, with tariffs and a new Congress adding uncertainty just as shippers finalize 2027 budgets.
What happened to shippers who played the spot market?
The freight recession's clearest casualty is the carrier relationship. Shippers who leaned heavily on the spot market kept few contracted carriers and, in Papa's words, "they're now paying the price" as rates climb and capacity tightens.
The remedy, he argued, is rebuilding strategic carrier relationships that slipped during the downturn — without overcorrecting. "You don't want to have too many carriers either," Papa said, since spreading volume too thin weakens a shipper's leverage with any single partner. Payment discipline is part of the equation: NFI holds a hard line that "we'll never go beyond 30-day payment terms."
Papa added that many shippers still treat carrier selection as a procurement event rather than a strategic one. Younger logistics professionals compound the challenge, because those who entered the industry during the past three years "have never dealt with a tight capacity market."
Why does transportation start before the dock?
With costs rising, customers who once ignored network advice are now listening. Papa described one shipper moving LTL freight from a Greater Philadelphia facility to Southern California. Its teams, he said, "focus on shipping, not delivery date" — rushing freight out the door the moment it becomes available.
NFI had long argued that holding and consolidating freight, running multi-stop truckload or using a cross-dock would improve both service and cost. When rates were low, the customer had no appetite for the discussion. Now, Papa said, it is willing to take that conversation across its organization, revisiting basics such as minimum order quantities and correcting the transit times stored in its ERP system.
"Transportation doesn't start when the product becomes available on the dock. It starts much sooner," Papa said, calling the trend a shift back "to much more of a supply chain conversation versus just transportation."
How is AI changing network design?
NFI has embedded AI into Vantage, its control tower, to run network analysis continuously rather than as a roughly once-a-year project. The system compares the past four to six weeks against the same period a year earlier and flags changes to NFI's operators — what Papa calls "a dynamic freight network design versus static."
The technology also detects new lanes lacking a contracted rate. When volume on such a lane justifies a mini bid, the system prompts a user to run one. That is the generative stage, Papa explained; the next stage is agentic, in which the bid goes out, the carrier rate is procured and the transportation management system updates automatically.
Papa does not expect the technology to displace people, calling it "an evolution." The goal is speed: by the time a quarterly review catches an issue, "it's too late." He predicted that "the days of doing annual or biannual network studies are going to be gone and replaced with a real-time network assessment."
What separates strong partners from the rest?
Asked what makes a carrier or partner worth keeping, Papa kept it simple: "those that will listen and collaborate," staying flexible as carrier networks change. When a carrier can no longer serve a lane as it once did, he said, the productive response is finding alternatives rather than insisting on a fix.
For shippers evaluating managed transportation providers, the green flag is a partner who raises supply chain issues beyond the dock door. The red flag is one focused on its own assets rather than the customer's outcome. "If you have to constantly bring ideas to them, that to me is a red flag versus them bringing ideas to you," Papa said. The best providers act as "an extension of their customers," joining annual operating plan discussions and hunting for synergies across NFI's book of business, such as backhaul matches between customers.
On outsourcing itself, Papa said logistics is a back-office function for most companies, while for NFI "it's front office." Customers running a TMS as software alone often see results fade after year one or two because they "don't have the ability to retain, train, and continue to advance their capabilities." NFI treats seasonal demand spikes as "a design variable," adjusting technology and resources rather than staffing to peak.
For 2027, Papa's advice came in two parts: build carrier relationships and "look beyond the dock." Shippers that do both, he said, will be better positioned for whatever the market does next.
Original: getfreightdata.com
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
929 articles