WW/SUPPLYCHAI

Filed 822W4M read

One number per supplier: a route to finding network bottlenecks

A PhD-backed method restates Goldratt's throughput question as CPM's lead-time question, so each supplier shares one number and the network bottleneck still surfaces.

By
Tom Whitfield
Filed
Length
822 words
Read
4 min
Projecting constraints in multi-tier supply chain networks: Two traditions, one measurement
Projecting constraints in multi-tier supply chain networks: Two traditions, one measurementmarcin049 / pixabay

Key points05

  • CPM dates to the late 1950s; Goldratt's Theory of Constraints arrived in 1984 with The Goal.
  • The method asks each firm for one number: company-level lead time, measured as inbound-to-outbound gate timestamps.
  • BOM-Batch conversion normalises per-batch process times to one finished vehicle, folding in shifts, maintenance and defect rates.
  • The midpoint-split disclosure strategy held across randomized networks under two input distributions and three network shapes.
  • Part 3 of the series publishes Tuesday, Nov. 17, with Part 4 on Nov. 24.

Every firm in a multi-tier supply network would hand over a single number — its company-level lead time — and from that alone, the network's bottleneck could be found. That is the proposal at the centre of Brian (Yoshiatsu) Kawabata's research, laid out in Part 2 of a four-part series on multi-tier supply chain networks, drawing on a PhD dissertation completed at Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology in June 2026 and a paper in Information Technology and Management (Springer, 2026).

Two traditions, one measurement

The Critical Path Method (CPM) emerged in the late 1950s, developed by Kelley, Walker, Malcolm and others alongside PERT, the Program Evaluation and Review Technique. It traces every route from raw material to finished product through thousands of processes; the longest route — the critical path — sets the completion time of the whole project. Its native setting, though, was the one-off project: construction, systems development, space programmes.

The Theory of Constraints (TOC) arrived later. Eliyahu Goldratt put it into the world in 1984 with The Goal, and its setting was the factory and repetitive production. TOC works with throughput — the rate of output — and in any system at least one node holds back total output. In a straight line, that node is simply the process with the lowest throughput capacity. Goldratt called it the bottleneck, or the constraint.

What connects the two?

The two frameworks have rarely been put on a single scale, and Kawabata points to a technical reason: their units are reciprocals. CPM's lead time is time per piece (time/pcs); TOC's throughput is pieces per unit of time (pcs/time). The same phenomenon, numerator and denominator swapped. Goldratt's own Critical Chain (CCPM) bridged the two, but only on the premise that every process duration was already in hand.

So Kawabata flips the problem. If TOC's question — which node has the lowest throughput? — can be restated as CPM's question — which route is longest by lead time? — then the data requirement collapses. No process-by-process capacity disclosures, which firms won't give anyway. Just one company-level lead time each, with disclosure held to a minimum. That thought seeded the idea of a platform to make bottlenecks visible across an entire supply chain network.

BOM-Batch conversion

One obstacle stands in the way first: processes count in wildly different units. A blast furnace pours tens of tons of steel at once across three shifts. A metal press stamps many screws in a single stroke, like a waffle iron. A car plant finishes vehicles one at a time. And one car needs four tires, two headlights, one steering wheel — so stringing together per-batch lead times from tire, lamp and steering-wheel plants is simply wrong. Operating hours, maintenance intervals and defect rates differ too.

The fix is what Kawabata calls BOM-Batch conversion. Every process is converted into one common unit: one finished vehicle, using the bill of materials. Shift patterns, maintenance stoppages and defect rates fold into the calculation — time spent producing defective parts counts, in effect, as idle time. Each figure should ideally carry a standard deviation, sample size and compilation period. The platform does the converting, on the condition that nothing is exposed to other firms.

What does each supplier actually share?

The company-level lead time has two possible measures. The approximation: the gap between a part's inbound gate timestamp and the product's outbound gate timestamp — data most firms already hold. The more precise route: summing the BOM-Batch-converted lead times along the internal path, counting work-in-process waiting time as a process in its own right. Where internal flows branch and converge like a river, the company-level figure is the longest internal route.

Where the search stops

The platform identifies bottlenecks at the granularity of the firm, not the process. Inside the factory gate, its search halts — and from there the road divides. A firm that doesn't know its own constraint faces a bisection search: the platform splits internal processes into upstream and downstream groups at the lead-time midpoint, asks which is longer, and narrows repeatedly. Some collateral leakage is unavoidable, but this midpoint split keeps it lowest — a result that held across randomized networks under two input distributions and three network shapes, the first of the dissertation's three simulations.

A firm that knows its own constraint — through digital transformation — discloses only that process's throughput capacity. Nothing else leaks. As Kawabata puts it: the better a firm understands its own interior, the less of it needs to be opened. In practice, every firm in the network shares one number, and only the firm projected to hold the network's bottleneck is asked anything more. Part 3, publishing Tuesday, Nov. 17, follows what improving that bottleneck sets in motion for the supplier, the OEM and the bank — and what each stands to gain.

Source: scmr.com

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

923 articles

Related05

  1. One Number Per Supplier: The Plan to Find Bottlenecks Without Full Disclosure

  2. A 20% Finished-Goods Buffer Beats Raw-Material Stock by 1.4x

  3. 84% of CSCOs Now Prioritise Resilience Over Cost: DP World

  4. When 10% Forecast Error Turns the Cheapest Supplier Into a Coin Flip

  5. North American factories reset supply networks for resilience in 2026

« PrevNext »