WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 736W4M read

NYC Amazon delivery overhaul could replace direct-hire mandate

New York City may replace Amazon’s direct-hire mandate with carrier or third-party options, while a compromise could protect 40 delivery partners and add city oversight.

By
Tom Whitfield
Filed
Length
736 words
Read
4 min
NYC lawmakers weigh overhaul of Amazon delivery worker bill
NYC lawmakers weigh overhaul of Amazon delivery worker billSohidullah007 / pixabay

Key points05

  • About 40 Amazon delivery service partners operate in New York City.
  • The current bill would require Amazon to directly hire thousands of delivery workers.
  • The compromise could allow Amazon to use UPS, the U.S. Postal Service or independent third-party operators.
  • On Nov. 19, Julie Menin said a revised bill could avoid job losses and closures of delivery partners.
  • A City Council vote could occur within a few weeks if negotiators reach agreement.

By Tom Whitfield

About 40 Amazon delivery service partners (DSPs) operate in New York City as lawmakers consider replacing the Delivery Protection Act’s direct-hire mandate with several ways to employ and contract for last-mile couriers.

The current bill would require Amazon.com Inc. to bring thousands of workers employed by subcontractors onto its own payroll. An overwhelming majority of City Council members and Mayor Zohran Mamdani back the measure. Amazon has threatened to pull its logistics operations out of New York if the requirement stands.

Its backers argue that outsourced workers face unsafe conditions while Amazon gains from lower-cost labor. Many of the 40 DSPs are minority-owned businesses whose owners fear the direct-hire proposal will put them out of business.

The revised operating choices

Lawmakers are discussing a menu of options that would let Amazon:

  • Hire couriers directly.
  • Use carriers such as UPS Inc. or the U.S. Postal Service.
  • Contract with fully independent third-party operators.

Amazon could also keep its DSP network under a compromise, but it would have to surrender control over routes, daily delivery quotas, hiring, firing and discipline. That is a complete change from the operating model the delivery companies use now, according to a person involved in the discussions.

The proposed revisions would remove the key direct-hire provision while preserving a role for local delivery businesses. They would still require Amazon and other operators of last-mile delivery facilities to obtain licenses from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. That city agency would investigate complaints and ensure safety standards are met.

The business opposition fractures

Amazon and small-business owners initially presented a united front against the bill. Amazon bankrolled a lobbying group that included many of its delivery partners, and those businesses opposed direct hiring. The alliance began to fracture when some owners started meeting city officials independently, according to a person familiar with the private negotiations.

Those owners wanted more transparency into how Amazon set delivery routes and determined the number of packages drivers had to handle during a shift. They also argued that their dependence on Amazon left them little bargaining leverage. The discussions persuaded bill sponsors that the small businesses needed protection from Amazon too, not only their drivers.

What does this change for shippers and carriers?

For the roughly 40 DSPs, the compromise offers a path to keep operating, but with less control over how they deploy labor and more city oversight.

For Amazon, it trades the risk of an exit from the city for reduced authority over its delivery network. UPS and USPS could become delivery channels, although the discussions disclose no carrier contracts or package-volume commitments.

For shippers using Amazon’s parcel network, the employer of last-mile couriers could change among Amazon, a parcel carrier or an independent operator. The reported terms set no parcel rates, package volumes or implementation schedule, leaving the commercial cost unresolved until the bill takes a firmer shape.

That company’s scale gives the relocation threat context: Amazon ranks No. 1 on Transport Topics’ Top 100 list of North America’s largest logistics companies, No. 1 on the TT Top 50 list of the largest global freight companies and No. 17 on the TT Top 100 private-carrier list.

The path to a Council vote

If negotiators settle the remaining differences, the legislation could reach a City Council vote within a few weeks. City Council Speaker Julie Menin’s spokesperson, Jack Lobel, said her office is working around the clock with the bill sponsor and stakeholders, and that several options remain under consideration.

Amazon spokesperson Steve Kelly said: “We appreciate that Speaker Julie Menin has met with numerous stakeholders on this bill, including us, and we’ll remain engaged with her and her team as work on the bill continues to try and reach the best outcome for New Yorkers.”

Menin told reporters Nov. 19 that she wanted the local delivery companies to remain able to operate. “I am confident we can chart a path forward with a bill that does not cause job loss and does not cause the DSPs to go out of business,” she said.

The next test is whether the Council schedules a vote within a few weeks. Without agreement, Amazon’s direct-hire fight and threat to move logistics operations out of New York will return to the center of the policy debate.

Source: ttnews.com

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

987 articles

Related05

  1. Amazon threatens NYC exit, citing $5 cost of direct-driver bill

  2. Freight Distress: 1,850 Jobs Cut Across Logistics, Manufacturing

  3. Amazon’s $5 delivery warning tests New York’s labor bill

  4. Amazon turns its delivery network into a carrier for hire in 2026

  5. Amazon Air Crash Revives Pilot Complaints Against 21 Air

« PrevNext »