WW/PORTSTERMI
Mixed-mode port automation requires SIL 2 or PL d safeguards
PEMA’s 2026 paper says mixed terminal traffic with fatal-accident risk typically requires SIL 2 or PL d safeguards, amid trade-offs over land, staffing and system safety.
- By
- Tom Whitfield
- Filed
- Length
- 631 words
- Read
- 3 min

Key points05
- PEMA’s 2026 paper says fatal-accident risk typically calls for SIL 2 under IEC 62061 or PL d under ISO 13849.
- ECT opened Rotterdam’s Delta/Sea-Land terminal on 25 June 1993, described as the world’s first automated container terminal.
- The segregated automated-terminal model challenged by PEMA is 33 years old.
- For minor risks, Performance Level c can support an acceptable risk mitigation.
- IEC TS 62998-1 is a 2019 technical specification now moving toward a full standard.
By Tom Whitfield
The Port Equipment Manufacturers Association’s (PEMA) 2026 information paper sets a concrete safety threshold for automated container terminals: unmanned cranes and vehicles sharing operating areas with manned road trucks typically require Safety Integrity Level 2 under IEC 62061 or Performance Level d under ISO 13849 where an accident could be fatal.
For minor risks, PEMA says Performance Level c can also lead to an acceptable risk mitigation. The paper therefore treats mixed traffic as a system-safety problem. Its alternative for non-safety-certified sensors makes the integrator responsible for safety across the assembled system.
Why did automation start with segregated lanes?
The template is 33 years old. On 25 June 1993, ECT opened the Delta/Sea-Land terminal in Rotterdam, which the operator, now Hutchison Ports ECT Rotterdam, describes as the world’s first automated container terminal.
In the end-loaded layout, stacks are worked from the ends and road trucks never enter the automated section. PEMA identifies this arrangement as the starting point for many automation projects. The geometry handles the interaction problem before equipment-level safeguards become the central issue.
The paper then challenges that model on land economics. Strict separation “may lead to inefficient land use and higher infrastructure costs due to fencing and dedicated driving lanes.” It gives no cost figure for either and includes no accident data. Its argument concerns layout, not a measured safety comparison.
What changes when trucks share an automated zone?
At terminals with high transhipment ratios, designers may choose quay-parallel stacks under cantilever cranes. Every crane then serves both quay and landside, but trucks and internal vehicles cannot be kept apart. In side-loaded layouts, road trucks drive under gantry cranes that may be unmanned.
That geometry places road traffic and unmanned equipment in the same working area. PEMA says safety concerns have been the main barrier to this kind of automation. Remote control of cranes, the usual answer so far, “increases the number of personnel required to operate the fleet.”
The commercial tension is plain. Strict separation can impose land and infrastructure costs through fencing and dedicated driving lanes. Remote control, by contrast, adds operating personnel. Mixed mode addresses the footprint problem, but PEMA makes system certification a condition rather than treating the mixed-traffic concept as automatically safe.
For shippers, carriers and forwarders, the practical question is whether a more compact terminal layout can operate without a higher incident risk. PEMA supplies no incident data with which to answer that, so its case rests on land economics and a proposed safety framework, not a measured safety comparison.
How should a terminal certify detection?
PEMA says sensors that detect people should carry certification for detection capability to a standard such as IEC TS 62998-1. Alternatively, an integrator can certify the whole system under ISO 13849 using sensors that do not carry safety certification; the integrator then assumes responsibility for safety at system level.
IEC TS 62998-1 is a technical specification from 2019. IEC now converts it into a full standard, with a draft out for committee vote. BSI and DIN also carry the draft. Terminals adopting mixed mode therefore face a moving certification baseline, even as PEMA identifies the functional-safety thresholds they need to meet.
Kari Rintanen of Konecranes and Alois Recktenwald of Siemens wrote IP33 Mixed Mode Automation, with contributions from LASE, SICK, IFM, EasyMile, Kalmar, VDL Automated Vehicles and BTG. PEMA published the paper this month.
The near-term policy test is whether IEC’s committee process converts IEC TS 62998-1 into a full standard and whether operators can meet any resulting safety framework. The outcome will shape whether mixed mode can deliver its land-efficiency case in terminals where trucks and automated equipment must share the working area.
Source: container-mag.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
923 articles
Related05
Antwerp-Bruges moves autonomous trucks from demo to revenue service
TÜV SÜD and Accenture promise 30% faster AMR certification
Venti to Put 100+ Autonomous Yard Trucks Into US Rail Terminals by 2027
Dongwon to pour KRW200bn into Busan New Port automation
Empiric Earth Proposes an Autonomous Truck Safety Test