WW/TRUCKINGRA
Median Trucking Verdict Quadruples to $3 Million, ATA Panel Warns
The median verdict against trucking companies jumped from $760,000 in 2023 to $3 million in the first half of this year, per the Institute for Legal Reform study cited at ATA's MCE.
- Desk
- Trucking & Rail
- By
- James Calloway
- Filed
- Length
- 472 words
- Read
- 2 min

Key points04
- Median verdict against trucking companies rose from $760,000 in 2023 to $3 million in the first half of this year (Institute for Legal Reform study).
- The Institute for Legal Reform cited six factors behind the jump at ATA's Management Conference & Exhibition.
- ADAS options include collision warning, lane departure/lane keeping, blind spot warning, and adaptive cruise control.
- Telematics should track hard braking, fast starts, tailgating, and speeding to drive coaching.
The median verdict against trucking companies hit $3 million in the first half of this year, up from $760,000 in 2023, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Institute for Legal Reform study cited at the American Trucking Associations (ATA) Management Conference & Exhibition (MCE). That is a near-quadrupling in under two years. Gino Fontana, COO and EVP at Transervice Logistics Inc., called the pattern out bluntly: "It seems like every other day we are hearing about some multimillion-dollar verdicts against trucking companies."
Why are verdicts climbing?
The Institute for Legal Reform flagged six drivers behind the jump at MCE:
- Interconnected fraud networks
- Reptile tactics and anchoring
- Flawed statutes and evidentiary rules
- New lawsuit targets
- Uncertain standards of care
- Third-party litigation funding
Several of these sit outside a fleet's control. Fontana argues managers still have moves to make. Fleets need to stay vigilant and look for patterns that could indicate staged accidents, then work with authorities to shut down the perpetrators of that fraud. He also urges fleet managers to press their legislators to review laws and enact regulations that prevent predatory litigation.
What can fleets actually control?
Truck specs, for one. Fontana recommends reviewing vehicle specifications to evaluate safety-related technologies that fit a fleet's operations. The menu of advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) is long: collision warning, lane departure and lane keeping, blind spot warning, and adaptive cruise control, among others.
But he draws a hard line on what the hardware does and doesn't do. Spec'ing ADAS options makes the truck safer, yet they do not take the place of a well-trained driver. The tech supports safer operations; it doesn't replace an attentive one.
Does coaching beat hardware?
In Fontana's framing, training is the backbone. Driver safety training must be an ongoing effort, not something confined to onboarding. Safe driving policies should explicitly outline and reinforce the use of cell phones and other distractions that contribute to distracted driving.
Telematics carries the coaching load. Devices should track hard braking, fast starts, following too closely, and speeding, and managers should use that data to coach drivers and improve habits. Recognition matters too: drivers who hit safety milestones deserve public acknowledgment.
Leadership engagement is the other half of the equation. Fleet leadership needs to speak about safety throughout the organization and, by their actions, show they are doing more than giving lip service to safety.
What's the outlook?
Reining in nuclear verdicts will take a coordinated effort spanning courts, legislators, and carriers, Fontana writes. In the near term, fleet managers and drivers can do their part by making sure their vehicles are spec'd with safety in mind and driven that way — the two levers, hardware and behavior, that remain fully in their control as litigation pressure keeps climbing.
Source: fleetowner.com
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.
921 articles
Related05
Nuclear Verdicts Force Trucking Industry to Rethink Legal Strategy
Trucking lawsuit verdicts average nearly $28 million, US Chamber finds
LA jury convicts two in $2M cargo theft ring using purchased carriers
Feds roll out new trucking fraud crackdown, Detroit News reports
ATA Tells Trump: Enforce the Rules or Lose America's Truckers