WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 676W3M read

Labor Department finalizes two-factor independent contractor rule

DOL's Nov. 19 final rule classifies independent contractors on two factors — control and profit opportunity — replacing the 2024 six-factor test. ATA says it shields 350,000 owner-operators.

By
Elena Vasquez
Filed
Length
676 words
Read
3 min
Labor Department finalizes independent contractor rule
Labor Department finalizes independent contractor rulechrissharkman / pixabay

Key points05

  • Labor Department finalized the independent contractor rule on Nov. 19, 2024-replacing six-factor test with two core factors.
  • ATA says the rule protects 350,000 independent truckers who choose contractor status.
  • The two factors are worker control over work and opportunity for profit or loss.
  • The rule reverses the Biden administration's 2024 six-factor totality-of-circumstances test.
  • Mark Colson becomes ATA president and CEO on Dec. 1.

The U.S. Department of Labor on Nov. 19 finalized a rule that classifies independent contractors primarily on just two factors — the worker's control over their work and their opportunity for profit or loss — replacing the Biden administration's six-factor test and handing a regulatory win to owner-operator truckers.

The American Trucking Associations says the rule protects roughly 350,000 independent truckers who choose to work as contractors. The classification question is far from academic: it determines whether a worker is entitled to overtime pay and the federal minimum wage under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

The rule has ping-ponged between administrations. The first Trump administration introduced a classification rule in January 2021 to streamline the process, relying on a similar two-factor approach. In 2024, the Biden administration swung back to a six-factor test before the current Trump administration's Labor Department restored the earlier framework.

What does the new test actually measure?

Under the final rule, the two core factors are the degree of control a worker has over their work and the opportunity for profit or loss based on the worker's initiative, their investment, or both.

The abandoned 2024 test was broader. It weighed:

  • opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill
  • investments by the worker and the potential employer
  • the degree of permanence of the work relationship
  • the nature and degree of control
  • whether the work was integral to the potential employer's business
  • the worker's skill and initiative

Under that approach, classification turned on the totality of the circumstances rather than any single factor. Some independent truckers — those who purchase or lease their own trucks and contract their services to motor carriers or haul freight directly for customers — spoke out against the 2024 change, arguing it would make it harder to remain classified as independent contractors.

Labor Department officials, including Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling, said the final rule provides clarity and will "reduce regulatory burdens on businesses." Officials said the rule includes detailed guidance and worked examples, including examples drawn specifically from the trucking industry.

Why carriers and owner-operators care

For motor carriers that run hybrid fleets — company drivers alongside independent contractors — the narrower test reduces the legal exposure that came with the six-factor framework, where factors such as the permanence of the relationship and how integral the work was to the business could tip a driver toward employee status.

Gregg Troian, ATA vice chair and president of PGT Trucking, framed the choice as one truckers make for autonomy. "We at PGT Trucking have company trucks. We employ drivers. … And at PGT Trucking, we also have independent contractors," he said at an event marking the rule's release. "Both pathways are respectable. Why do truckers go independent? They want to set their own hours, they want schedule flexibility and they want to choose their own routes and they also get to choose their length of haul."

Troian said the rule would "protect independent truckers," which would in turn "protect the supply chain every family relies on."

Mark Colson, who becomes president and CEO of American Trucking Associations on Dec. 1 after leading the Alabama Trucking Association since 2019, drew on his own family's experience running a tire shop. He said the rule would open more opportunities for female truckers who choose independence for flexibility, and he asked independent truckers Emily Plummer and Tina Klein to stand and be recognized at the event.

"Many of today's truckers want to be entrepreneurs," Colson said. "They want what my grandfather found when he started his tire shop. Ultimately, this rule empowers today's professionals. It protects small businesses and gives them certainty to grow and plan their future."

The rule's Nov. 19 finalization closes — for now — a definitional fight that has flipped with each change of administration, giving owner-operators and the carriers that contract with them a clearer, less litigious standard heading into 2027, when EPA's tougher NOx standard adds a fresh layer of compliance cost to fleet decisions.

Source: ttnews.com

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

977 articles

Related05

  1. DOL keeps contractor test, wins trucking support in final rule

  2. Final U.S. rule protects more than 350,000 independent truckers

  3. New Jersey's ABC Test for Independent Contractors Now in Effect

  4. 2026 Elections Set to Rewrite Trucking Labor Rules Either Way

  5. Trucking Groups Applaud Sonderling Confirmation as Labor Secretary

« PrevNext »