WW/TRUCKINGRA

Filed 787W4M read

Four rail unions back UP–NS merger as shippers cry retaliation

Four rail unions endorse the UP–NS merger with 'Jobs for Life' deals, CEO Vena apologizes for rate-hike 'humor,' and CN demands Midwest access as STB review runs to 2027.

By
Marcus Bennett
Filed
Length
787 words
Read
4 min
Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger draws labor support, shipper concerns
Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger draws labor support, shipper concernsfancycrave1 / pixabay

Key points04

  • UP and NSC project the merged network could shift ~2.1 million truckloads from highway to rail annually
  • STB decision on the merger not expected until 2027; public comment deadline was Nov. 19
  • Four unions signed 'Jobs for Life' agreements contingent on merger approval
  • CN signed a July MOU with UP and agreed not to oppose the deal in exchange for Midwest access rights

Four rail labor organizations have formally endorsed the Union Pacific–Norfolk Southern merger, while Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena issued his first public apology for remarks that appeared to threaten rate hikes against unsupportive shippers — and the Surface Transportation Board is not expected to rule until 2027.

The endorsements and the apology landed amid a flurry of filings at the Nov. 19 deadline for public comments in the STB proceeding. Union Pacific (NYSE: UNP) and Norfolk Southern (NYSE: NSC) urged the board to keep the review moving, pushing back on Canadian Pacific Kansas City's request to terminate it outright. The companies say the combination would create the nation's first single-line, seamless coast-to-coast railroad.

What did Vena actually say?

Vena broke his silence on remarks he made at a March conference of the Southwest Association of Rail Shippers, where he suggested shippers who failed to support the merger could face rate increases. His explanation: it was a joke.

"I do use humor in my presentations to keep the audience engaged, including in my presentation at the conference of the Southwest Association of Rail Shippers this past March," Vena said. "I know what I said and regret the inference."

He noted the speech ran more than 50 minutes and that the attempted humor came near its conclusion. "I apologize to anyone who misunderstood my statement," he said.

An apology framed around misunderstanding is not a retraction of the underlying words — a distinction chemical shippers were quick to draw.

Why are the unions on board?

The SMART Transportation Division, the National Conference of Firemen and Oilers, the International Brotherhood of Boilermakers and SMART's Mechanical Division filed joint comments urging approval. Each has signed a "Jobs for Life" agreement with UP and NSC — career-long employment commitments for covered workers, contingent on the deal closing and subject to their respective terms.

"For generations, railroaders have been asked to carry the uncertainty while somebody else makes the decisions," SMART-TD President Jeremy Ferguson said. "We went to the bargaining table and secured binding commitments to our members' futures."

For SMART-TD members, the protections guard against involuntary furlough in their crafts, under their collective bargaining agreements and within current seniority districts. The other unions negotiated terms tailored to their memberships.

The coalition conditioned its support on the employment commitments being honored in full, effective safety and service oversight, and continued labor involvement during implementation.

Can the merger really move 2.1 million truckloads?

UP and NSC estimate the combined network could shift approximately 2.1 million truckloads from highways to rail annually. The unions argue a more connected network with fewer interchange delays would let railroads compete for freight now moving by truck, generating railroad work while cutting highway congestion and heavy-truck traffic.

"Every load we win back to rail is an opportunity for railroaders to show what we do best," said Michael Pistone, president of the National Conference of Firemen and Oilers. "America needs a supply chain that can carry more freight safely and reliably."

The 2.1 million figure is a company projection, not an audited forecast — and it anchors both the labor case and the carriers' public-interest argument.

What are shippers afraid of?

The American Chemistry Council warned the proceeding faces more than unusual scale and new review standards.

"This merger application differs from many that have come before it — not only because of its magnitude and the new standards of review, but also because it is being considered under a dark cloud amid concerns about potential retaliation against those who speak out," the council said.

What does CN want in exchange?

Canadian National (NYSE: CNI) filed proposed conditions with the STB aimed at preserving customer options and expanding its Midwest access, building on a binding memorandum of understanding signed with Union Pacific in July. CN agreed not to oppose the transaction as part of that deal.

Its four requests:

  • Kansas City: Acquire UP's Kansas City–St. Louis line and secure access to Neff Yard.
  • St. Louis and East St. Louis: Improve connectivity and rail access, including shorter routes for certain shipments.
  • Des Moines and Avon, Iowa: Preserve access to at least two Class I railroads for affected customers.
  • Illinois: Protect existing rail competition and customer choice.

The framework also has CN acquiring Norfolk Southern's interests in the Kansas City Terminal Railway and the Terminal Railroad Association of St. Louis, plus new Midwest access rights. Everything depends on STB approval.

If approved, the merger would reshape North American logistics. Whether a coast-to-coast network delivers the service gains and freight growth its proponents project is precisely what the STB's review — stretching to 2027 — will have to test.

Original: getfreightdata.com

Share this article:

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

1,006 articles

Related05

  1. Union Pacific CEO calls rate-hike threat remark 'humor' as STB orders video release

  2. UP CEO's Rate Threat Video Goes Public, Complicating NS Merger

  3. Union Pacific CEO '99.99%' Sure STB Clears $85bn NS Deal

  4. STB rejects Union Pacific appeal, orders Vena speech video public

  5. Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger divides rail leaders

« PrevNext »