WW/SUPPLYCHAI

Filed 666W3M read

CargoWise rivals smell blood after pricing revolt, but choice stays thin

WiseTech holds CargoWise rollouts at 13 of the top 25 forwarders, yet rivals and regulators on two continents are testing how much choice the market truly has.

By
Amara Osei
Filed
Length
666 words
Read
3 min
CargoWise has more challengers. But how much choice do forwarders really have?
CargoWise has more challengers. But how much choice do forwarders really have?StartupStockPhotos / pixabay

Key points05

  • 13 of the world's 25 largest forwarders had CargoWise rollouts as of 30 June
  • The ACCC required WiseTech and BluJay to divest Expedient, acquired via e2open
  • An August submission asked the European Commission to monitor WiseTech's market reach
  • Magaya won EP Logistics (January) and CMS Shipping (May) as CargoWise switchers
  • WiseTech overhauled CargoWise pricing in December

WiseTech has landed CargoWise rollouts with 13 of the world's 25 largest forwarders as of 30 June — a figure that tells you exactly how much "choice" the market really offers. Everything else in this story is detail around that number.

The detail still matters. When WiseTech overhauled CargoWise pricing last December, forwarders told The Loadstar they had few realistic alternatives. That's slowly changing. FreightSuite and Shipthis are now pitching themselves as direct CargoWise replacements. GoFreight is courting the same customers. Magaya has gone further and named names: two forwarders it says chose its software over CargoWise.

What does the competition actually look like?

Magaya hasn't been shy about it. On its website, the company said: "CargoWise, built by WiseTech Global, has long dominated the highest enterprise tier of freight forwarding software. Magaya was built for a different kind of company: small to mid-market freight forwarders and customs brokers who run integrated warehouse operations, value responsive support, and need software they can actually go live on without a six-month project and a dedicated consultant."

It added: "That distinction has always existed, but recent events at WiseTech Global have brought it into sharp focus, prompting forwarders across the industry to take a hard look at what they're paying, what they're getting, and what alternatives look like."

Sharp words. The wins are real, if modest. Magaya said in January that EP Logistics had picked its software to replace CargoWise across US and Mexican operations. In May came a second name: Montreal-based CMS Shipping.

Meanwhile WiseTech counters with Blue Water Shipping and XPD Global among contracts won under its new pricing model. The incumbent isn't exactly bleeding.

What are the regulators doing?

Regulators have taken notice on two continents. In August, a submission seen by The Loadstar asked the European Commission to monitor whether CargoWise's reach and WiseTech's acquisitions could make it harder for forwarders to switch — or for rival vendors to connect to customs systems on equal terms. The submission alleged no breach of competition law. The commission said it had put the information on file. Filed, not actioned. Draw your own conclusions.

Australia went further. The ACCC accepted a court-enforceable undertaking from WiseTech and its subsidiary BluJay to divest Expedient, a logistics software business acquired through e2open. The regulator said WiseTech already had substantial market power, and that putting CargoWise and Expedient under one roof reduced choice for Australian customers. WiseTech and BluJay disputed that assessment.

Can anyone actually beat CargoWise for the big accounts?

Here the rivals get honest. "There is really no alternative to CargoWise for the biggest global forwarders," Benjamin Riege of Germany's Riege Software told The Loadstar in February. "But when you're a medium-sized forwarder, of course we are a choice."

For a multinational, switching is less a software decision than a customs audit with teeth. Staff must file declarations from the new platform in every country where branches operate. Finance teams need to keep invoicing while open jobs and unbilled charges migrate. Records must stay retrievable for auditors. Any one of those can stall a migration for months.

AI might speed up part of the problem. One freight software executive told The Loadstar AI could help vendors build customs integrations faster, but "the actual government sign-off is always going to be the bottleneck". The same executive sees a bigger prize: "The system of record is going to be what owns the AI and the process, going forward." Which, conveniently, is the segment CargoWise already owns.

Where does this leave forwarders?

The realistic near-term gain isn't a mass exodus. It's leverage. A credible alternative gives forwarders more room to negotiate on price and support at the next CargoWise renewal — even if they decide to stay. With regulators in Brussels and Canberra now watching, WiseTech's pricing conversations may get a little more polite, and the next renewal cycle should show whether that leverage is real.

Source: The Loadstar

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Ocean and air freight, container shipping at Waybill Wire.

968 articles

Related05

  1. WiseTech's air cargo push puts pressure on independent booking platforms

  2. WiseTech opens CargoWise to GSSAs, pressuring air booking platforms

  3. LATAM Cargo bets biggest non-freighter spend on digital overhaul

  4. Delta Cargo plugs into CargoWise in push to automate air freight bookings

  5. SaaS Now Half of Loadsmart's Gross Profit as CEO Maps Post-Downturn Pivot

« Prev